Adam Isacson

Get daily links in your email

Developments

This month will mark two years since the Biden administration inaugurated a program allowing citizens of Venezuela to reside in the United States with a two-year humanitarian parole status. Now, CBS News revealed, the administration does not plan to allow Venezuelan citizens to renew their humanitarian parole. If they do not seek to adjust their status, Venezuelan parole recipients will find themselves in legal limbo, subject to removal should the government in Caracas allow deportation flights to resume.

The parole program allows people to apply online from elsewhere and arrive by air, avoiding the U.S.-Mexico border. It has been available for up to a combined 30,000 citizens a year of Venezuela and, after January 2023, of Cuba, Haiti, and Nicaragua, who have valid passports and U.S.-based sponsors. Mexico used the program’s existence to justify accepting up to 30,000 monthly land-border deportations of those countries’ citizens.

Venezuelans who arrived in the United States before July 2023 are eligible to apply for Temporary Protected Status, a non-permanent but firmer documented status. As a result, for the next eight or nine months at least, most Venezuelans facing expiration of their parole have another option. It is unclear what might happen after that, or what might happen to citizens of Cuba, Haiti, and Nicaragua whose two-year statuses will begin to expire in January. The outcome of the November 2024 election will be a big factor.

• Camilo Montoya-Galvez, “U.S. Won’t Extend Legal Status for Venezuelan Migrants Who Arrived Under Biden Program” (CBS News, October 3, 2024).

Mexico began reckoning with an October 1 killing of six migrants by Mexican Army soldiers in the southern state of Chiapas. Another 10 were wounded.

That evening, soldiers chased, then fired on, a pickup truck carrying 33 migrants about 50 miles inland from the Guatemala border. Mexico’s Defense Secretariat (SEDENA) claimed that the vehicle “evaded military personnel” and that soldiers heard “detonations.”

Mexico’s newly inaugurated president, Claudia Sheinbaum, called the incident “deplorable,” adding, “a situation like this cannot be repeated.” Sheinbaum said that civilian prosecutors are questioning the two soldiers who fired their weapons; they have not yet been charged with anything.

Mexico’s Senate began its Thursday session with a moment of silence for the shooting’s victims.

The Human Mobility Pastoral, part of the Episcopal Conference of Mexico’s Catholic church, condemned the shooting as “the consequence of the militarization of migration policy and a greater presence of the armed forces on the southern border.” Added a statement from numerous Mexican human rights organizations: “Mexico has chosen to implement a migration policy without a human rights focus, making use of military forces, such as the National Guard, the Navy or the Army, as mechanisms for migration control.”

• Mark Stevenson, “6 Migrants From Egypt, Peru and Honduras Die Near Guatemalan Border After Mexican Soldiers Open Fire” (Associated Press, Associated Press, October 3, 2024).
• Patrick J. Mcdonnell, “Mexico Vows Inquiry After Soldiers Fire on U.S.-Bound Migrants, Killing Six” (The Los Angeles Times, October 3, 2024).
• Graciela Olvera, “Episcopado Mexicano Condena Muerte de Migrantes en Chiapas” (Milenio (Mexico), October 3, 2024).
• “Asesinato de Migrantes en Chiapas Es “Consecuencia de las Politicas Migratorias” del Estado Mexicano: Colectivo de Monitoreo–Frontera Sur” (Desinformemonos, October 3, 2024).
• “Claudia Sheinbaum Condena Muerte de Migrantes Abatidos por Soldados Mexicanos al Ser “Confundidos” Con Narcotraficantes” (La Hora (Guatemala), October 3, 2024).
• “Religiosos Piden a Sheinbaum una Frontera «Fraterna» y No «Militarizada»” (EFE, Efecto Cocuyo (Venezuela), October 3, 2024).
• Gabriela Coutino, “Cuatro Migrantes Atacados por el Ejercito Son Dados de Alta y Dos Mas Estan Graves” (Proceso (Mexico), October 3, 2024).
• Lliliana Padilla, Silvia Arellano, “Senado Guarda un Minuto de Silencio por Migrantes Fallecidos” (Milenio (Mexico), October 3, 2024).

At a September 30 meeting of the Texas House Committee on State Affairs, Texas Public Radio reported, a court administration official revealed that U.S. citizens were 72 percent of those accused of smuggling immigrants in the state between May 2023 and April 2024. Less than 10 percent were from Mexico.

• Julián Aguilar, “Texas Lawmakers Told Most People Accused of Smuggling Migrants Into State Are U.S. Citizens” (Texas Public Radio, October 3, 2024).

The conservative news website The Center Square published unofficial data indicating that Border Patrol apprehended at least 1,525,210 migrants in fiscal year 2024, which ended on September 30. This number, however, seems slightly low: it would indicate that Border Patrol apprehended just 48,505 migrants in September (the agency’s reported October-August total was 1,476,705). Other sources have reported that September’s apprehensions totaled about 54,000.

• Bethany Blankley, “Exclusive: At Least 1.5 Million Illegal Southwest Border Crossers Reported in fy24” (The Center Square, October 3, 2024).

Analyses and Feature Stories

In the first of a series about regional human rights and democracy challenges for the next U.S. administration, WOLA published five sets of principles to guide border and migration policy. They cover human rights and accountability, upholding asylum, comprehensive immigration reform, root causes, and regional cooperation and integration.

• “Migration: Five Policies That Protect Human Rights and Human Dignity” (Washington Office on Latin America, October 3, 2024).

In a Wilson Center interview, journalist Molly O’Toole explored how global migration patterns are transforming due to U.S. policies, economic conditions, and environmental crises. That is the overarching subject of O’Toole’s forthcoming book The Route, which traces migration from Brazil to the U.S.-Mexico border. “It’s very difficult to think of a policy that the U.S. could conceive of that could stop people who are willing to die in order to make it,” she pointed out.

• Molly O’Toole, “Global Migration And “The Route” to the US” (Woodrow Wilson Center, October 3, 2024).

By declaring Mexican and Venezuelan criminal groups to be “terrorist organizations”—something the federal government has not done—Texas Gov. Greg Abbott (R) is carrying out a parallel foreign policy, noted an analysis by Francesca D’Annunzio at the Texas Observer.

• Francesca D’Annunzio, “Abbott’s Border ‘Theatrics’ Now Include Acting Like the State Department” (The Texas Observer, October 3, 2024).

“Democrats have traveled a long arc in the last four years,” reads a New York Times newsletter from Hamed Aleaziz. “When Biden took office, he spoke warmly of migrants seeking asylum and even tried to pause deportations altogether. (A court said no.) As his political fortunes sank, he turned toward deterring migrants. Finally, in June, he took a hard line.”

• Hamed Aleaziz, “A Crackdown” (The New York Times, October 4, 2024).

“The effect of immigration on wages is one of the most thoroughly studied topics in empirical economics, and the results are clear: Immigrants do not make native-born workers worse off, and probably make them better off,” explained Rogé Karma in an Atlantic essay.

• Roge Karma, “The Truth About Immigration and the American Worker” (The Atlantic, October 3, 2024).

On the Right

• Phillip Linderman, “How to Break the Sanctuary States” (Center for Immigration Studies, The American Conservative, October 4, 2024).

Get daily links in your email

Developments

Mexican Army soldiers chased, then fired on, a truck carrying 33 migrants on the evening of October 1, killing 6 of them and wounding 12. The incident took place on the Pacific coastal highway in Huixtla, Chiapas, about 50 miles from Mexico’s border with Guatemala.

Mexico’s Defense Secretariat (SEDENA) issued a statement claiming that the migrants’ truck “evaded military personnel,” who suspected that it was tied to organized crime, which has become much more active in the state of Chiapas over the past year. That alone does not justify use of lethal force; the SEDENA statement contended that soldiers fired at the truck after hearing “detonations.”

The deceased victims were reportedly from Nepal, Egypt and Pakistan. Other migrants aboard the vehicle, including some of the wounded, came from Cuba, India, and what SEDENA called “Arab nationalities.” The Foreign Ministry of Peru claimed that one of the six fatalities was a Peruvian citizen.

SEDENA stated that the two soldiers who fired their weapons have been removed from their posts, and that both the civilian and military justice systems’ prosecutors are investigating. The incident heightens concerns about the Mexican government’s expanding placement of combat-trained soldiers in internal law-enforcement roles.

“People in mobility are exposed to great risks during their journey, that is why it is essential to have legal ways of access, transit and integration to avoid tragedies like this,” read a brief statement from UNHCR.

• “Sedena Informa Sobre Hechos Ocurridos en Chiapas” (Secretaria de Defensa Nacional (Mexico), October 2, 2024).
• Antonio Zebadua, “Disparan Militares a Migrantes en Villa Comaltitlan; 6 Muertos y 12 Heridos” (El Diario del Sur (Chiapas Mexico), October 2, 2024).
• Emiliano Rodriguez Mega, James Wagner, “Mexican Military Fatally Shoots Six Migrants” (The New York Times, October 2, 2024).
• Edgar H. Clemente, “6 Migrants Shot Dead Near Guatemalan Border When Mexican Army Troops Open Fire” (Associated Press, Associated Press, October 2, 2024).
• Lizbeth Diaz, “Six Migrants Die After Mexican Soldiers Fire on Pick-Up Truck” (Reuters, Reuters, October 2, 2024).
• “Mexican Soldiers Kill Six After Opening Fire on Truck Carrying Migrants” (Al Jazeera, October 3, 2024).
• Rob Corp, “Six Migrants Killed After Mexico Soldiers Open Fire” (BBC (UK), October 2, 2024).
• Angel Hernandez, “Peruano Murio en Agresion de Soldados a Migrantes en Chiapas” (Milenio (Mexico), October 2, 2024).
• Gabriela Coutino, “El Ejercito Mata en Chiapas a Migrantes de Egipto, Nepal y Pakistan” (Proceso (Mexico), October 2, 2024).
• Gloria Leticia DÍaz, “La Sedena Responsabiliza a Dos Soldados de los Disparos Contra Migrantes en Chiapas” (Proceso (Mexico), October 2, 2024).
• Gabriela Coutino, “Oim y Acnur Expresan su Preocupacion por Asesinato de Migrantes a Manos del Ejercito” (Proceso (Mexico), October 2, 2024).
• “Mata el Ejercito a Seis Migrantes en Chiapas al “Confundirlos”Con Crimen Organizado; Hay 10 Lesionados Mas” (Animal Politico (Mexico), October 2, 2024).
• Carlos Alvarez Acevedo, “Militares Asesinan a 6 Migrantes en Chiapas; Los Confundieron Con Delincuentes” (Revista Zeta (Tijuana Mexico), October 2, 2024).
• Fernando Ortiz, “Muerte-de-Migrantes en Operativo-Militar en-Chiapas-Preocupa a-Onu” (Milenio (Mexico), October 2, 2024).
• Mauricio Ortiz, “Indagan a Militares por Muerte de Migrantes en Huixtla, Chiapas” (Milenio (Mexico), October 2, 2024).

Border Report pointed out new FBI data showing that violent crime rates in Texas border cities are lower than the average for all cities. All Texas border communities have homicide rates below the 2023 U.S. national average of 5.7 per 100,000 inhabitants.

• Sandra Sanchez, “Texas Border Communities Again Safer From Violent Crimes, New Fbi Data Shows” (Border Report, October 2, 2024).

The Department of Homeland Security’s (DHS) annual Homeland Threat Assessment document, released October 2, warned that “over the next year, we expect some individuals with terrorism ties and some criminal actors will continue their efforts to exploit migration flows and the complex border security environment to enter the United States.”

• “Dhs’ 2025 Homeland Threat Assessment Indicates the Threat of Domestic and Foreign Terrorism in the Homeland Remains High” (Department of Homeland Security, October 2, 2024).
• Louis Casiano, “Illegal Immigrants With ‘Terrorism Ties’ Will Continue to Exploit Border, Homeland Security Report Warns” (Fox News, October 3, 2024).
• Victor Nava, “Dhs Threat Report Warns Migrants With ‘Terrorism Ties’ Will Continue to Exploit Border Crisis” (The New York Post, October 2, 2024).

In Washington, DC district court, a Trump-appointed judge ruled that the Biden administration violated environmental law when it halted border-wall construction in 2021. Judge Trevor McFadden argued that Biden’s border policies encouraged more migration, and migrants littered trash in border areas.

• Andrew Stanton, “Trump Judge Rules Biden Canceling Border Wall Broke Environmental Law” (Newsweek, October 2, 2024).

NewsNation reported, based on an internal Border Patrol alert, that the Northeast Cartel, active in parts of Mexico’s border state of Tamaulipas across from south Texas, has been using electronic devices to disrupt the agency’s surveillance drones.

• Ali Bradley, Jeff Arnold, “Mexican Cartels Using Devices to Disrupt U.S. Drones” (NewsNation, October 2, 2024).

Analyses and Feature Stories

The American Immigration Council (AIC) released a report about the potential cost of massively deporting undocumented migrants from the United States, which is a core campaign promise of Republican candidate Donald Trump.

It estimated that arresting, detaining, processing, and removing a million undocumented migrants each year would cost an annual total of $88 billion. It would total at least $315 billion for a one-time operation and $967.9 billion for a decade-long campaign.

Deporting about 4 percent of the U.S. workforce would cause the nation’s gross domestic product to “drop anywhere from 4.2% to 6.8%,” the AIC found; that is more than during the 2007-2009 “Great Recession.”

The report’s scope did not extend to the harder-to-quantify costs to human rights and democratic institutions that a mass-deportation campaign might entail, or the harm to U.S. civil-military relations if such a campaign were to mobilize Defense Department resources and personnel.

• “Mass Deportation: Devastating Costs to America, Its Budget and Economy” (American Immigration Council, October 2, 2024).
• Aaron Reichlin-Melnick, “New Report Shows the Devastating Costs of Mass Deportation” (American Immigration Council, October 2, 2024).

The ACLU has filed suit in federal court to obtain results of a Freedom of Information Act request about federal government capacity, and potential costs, of a “mass deportation” effort.

• Lauren Villagran, “Aclu Sues Feds, Questions Infrastructure for Mass Deportation” (USA Today, October 2, 2024).

The Associated Press fact-checked a column graph of U.S.-Mexico border migrant apprehensions that Republican candidate Donald Trump frequently displays at campaign events; he was gesturing at it when a would-be assassin’s bullet grazed his ear at a July campaign event. The chart includes errors and distortions, including a marker showing Trump leaving office in April 2020, the first full month of the COVID pandemic, when migration plummeted. Trump in fact left office in January 2021, after several months of increased migrant apprehensions.

• Adriana Gomez Licon, “How Trump Credits an Immigration Chart for Saving His Life — and What the Chart Is Missing” (Associated Press, Associated Press, October 3, 2024).

Washington Post columnist Philip Bump rebutted claims, including those made by JD Vance in Tuesday’s vice-presidential candidates’ debate, that migrants are contributing to crime, fentanyl smuggling, and higher U.S. housing costs. PolitiFact, the Associated Press, and Melvis Acosta at Mother Jones addressed other spurious claims made in the debate, including Vance’s allegation that DHS has “effectively lost” 320,000 unaccompanied migrant children.

• Philip Bump, “Republicans Keep Inventing New Ways to Scapegoat Immigrants” (The Washington Post, October 2, 2024).
• “2024 Vp Debate: Fact-Checking Jd Vance and Tim Walz” (PolitiFact, October 2, 2024).
• Melvis Acosta, “Don’t Let Vance Fool You—Trump Would Separate Millions of Families.” (Mother Jones, October 2, 2024).

The Project on Government Oversight published allegations that DHS Inspector General Joseph Cuffari, a key official for oversight of border security agencies, has engaged in a prolonged effort to undermine investigations into his own misconduct, especially claims of whistleblower retaliation. Cuffari is under investigation by the Integrity Committee, a federal panel that oversees inspectors-general, for retaliating against whistleblowers who reported delays in DHS reports, including a report on migrant family separations.

• Nick Schwellenbach, “A Watchdog’s War on Oversight” (Project on Government Oversight, October 2, 2024).

On the Right

• Robert Henneke, “Harris Really Does Have a Magic Wand for the Border” (Texas Public Policy Foundation, The Hill, October 2, 2024).
• Joseph Curl, “Why Democrats Have Opened America’s Southern Border” (The Washington Times, October 2, 2024).

Get daily links in your email

Developments

The border and migration were the third topic that CBS News moderators posed to candidates JD Vance and Tim Walz in last night’s vice-presidential debate.

Asked about the Trump campaign’s “mass deportation” plans, Vance replied that, if elected, Donald Trump would first focus on deporting migrants with criminal records in the United States; the Ohio Senator did not address the question’s inquiry about whether it would separate families. Vance blamed Walz’s running mate, Kamala Harris, and President Joe Biden for “94 executive orders suspending deportations, decriminalizing illegal aliens, massively increasing the asylum fraud that exists in our system, that has opened the floodgates,” and sought to tie that to fentanyl smuggling.

Walz, the governor of Minnesota, repeated the Harris campaign’s charge that Donald Trump torpedoed a compromise bipartisan border-security bill in February 2024 by urging Republican senators to vote against it. That bill, the “Border Act of 2024,” failed in the Senate after months of negotiations between a group of Democratic and Republican senators. As it sought Republican buy-in, that bill included tougher provisions than Democrats would normally support, like severe limits on asylum access between ports of entry, more migrant detention capacity, and expenditure of Trump-era border wall funds. Vance did not address the “Border Act,” which he voted against.

Walz incorrectly claimed that Donald Trump built “less than 2 percent” of border wall (the net increase in fenced-off miles was about 4 percent, but Trump built new pedestrian fencing over 14 percent of the border). Vance incorrectly claimed that there are “20, 25 million illegal aliens who are here in the country” (there were 11 million in 2022); that “we have 320,000 children that the Department of Homeland Security has effectively lost” (32,000 children—starting in 2019, when Trump was president—have missed immigration hearings but aren’t necessarily “missing,” while another 291,000 haven’t been issued Notices to Appear but aren’t “missing”); and that the CBP One program is illegal (it employs humanitarian parole, a presidential authority dating back to 1952). As has been documented by a Cato Institute review of obtained official documents, among other sources, the vast majority of fentanyl is smuggled by U.S. citizens, or by non-citizens with border-crossing credentials who are not migrants.

The segment ended with CBS moderator Margaret Brennan fact-checking Vance’s claim that Haitian migrants in Springfield, Ohio are not legally in the United States (nearly all have documentation, mainly humanitarian parole or Temporary Protected Status). “The rules were that you guys were going to fact check,” Vance complained; the border-migration discussion ended when moderators muted the candidates’ microphones.

• “Read the Full Vp Debate Transcript From the Walz-Vance Showdown” (CBS News, October 2, 2024).
• Anna Giaritelli, “Vance Outlines Trump Mass Deportation Plan at Debate” (The Washington Examiner, October 1, 2024).
• Stephen Dinan, “Walz Complains Trump Only Built 2% of Border Wall” (The Washington Times, October 1, 2024).
• Pema Levy, “Vance Says He’s Pro-Family. Just Not Keeping Families Together.” (Mother Jones, October 1, 2024).
• Ashleigh Jackson, “Vance Called Harris a ‘Border Czar’ During the Vp Debate. What Does That Mean?” (Nexstar, The Hill, October 1, 2024).
• “Culpan a Harris y Trump de Crisis Migratoria en Debate de Walz y Vance” (EFE, Milenio (Mexico), October 1, 2024).

The Venezuelan daily Tal Cual reported that while in Mexico to speak on a panel, a Cuban vice minister of labor and social security got a CBP One appointment at the Arizona border, was released into the United States, and now has a date to appear in immigration court in August 2026.

• “Viceministro de Trabajo Cubano Pidio Asilo en Estados Unidos” (Tal Cual (Venezuela), October 1, 2024).

Analyses and Feature Stories

Departed Mexican president Andrés Manuel López Obrador’s “control of the migration valve may have insulated his government from Washington’s meddling,” Eduardo Porter wrote at the Washington Post. “But that tense, unstable equilibrium is unlikely to survive under the government of López Obrador’s anointed successor Claudia Sheinbaum.”

• Eduardo Porter, “Whom Does Mexico Favor in November?” (The Washington Post, October 1, 2024).

On the Right

• Andy Biggs, “Gop Rep: Kamala Refused to Face Her Failure at the Border” (Newsweek, October 1, 2024).

Get daily links in your email

Developments

The Biden administration published a revised proclamation and a final rule tightening restrictions, first issued on June 4, on migrants’ ability to access the U.S. asylum system without making appointments at official border crossings (ports of entry). Since then, most who cross between the ports of entry and enter Border Patrol custody are ineligible for asylum.

The rule’s first version revoked asylum access whenever the daily average of Border Patrol’s migrant apprehensions exceeds 2,500 over a 7-day period, and would have restored asylum when Border Patrol apprehensions fall below 1,500 over a 7-day period, excluding unaccompanied children.

The new version cements the asylum restrictions further: the daily average would now have to remain below 1,500 per day over 28 days—not 7—and unaccompanied children now count toward the total.

According to Border Patrol data from July, August, and (preliminarily) September, the agency averaged 1,831 apprehensions per day during those months, including 194 unaccompanied children per day (in July and August). That is well over the 1,500-per-day threshold below which apprehensions would need to fall, over 28 days, in order to “turn back on” the right to seek asylum again between ports of entry.

Section 208 of the Immigration and Nationality Act guarantees the right to seek asylum to all who are physically present in the United States “whether or not at a designated port of arrival.”

• “A Proclamation on Amending Proclamation 10773” (The White House, September 30, 2024).
• “Securing the Border” (Executive Office for Immigration Review, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, Federal Register, September 30, 2024).
• “Fact Sheet: Joint Dhs-Doj Final Rule Issued to Restrict Asylum Eligibility for Those Who Enter During High Encounters at the Southern Border” (Department of Homeland Security, September 30, 2024).
• Camilo Montoya-Galvez, “Biden Shores Up Asylum Limits, Likely Extending Border Crackdown Indefinitely” (CBS News, September 30, 2024).
• Nick Miroff, “Biden Expands Asylum Restrictions That Sharply Curbed Border Crossings” (The Washington Post, September 30, 2024).
• Rafael Bernal, Rebecca Beitsch, “Biden Administration Expands Asylum Restrictions at Southern Border” (The Hill, September 30, 2024).
• Hamed Aleaziz, “Biden Expands Asylum Restrictions at the Southern Border” (The New York Times, September 30, 2024).
• Ellen M. Gilmer, “Biden Locks in Asylum Curbs as Democrats Combat Border Flak” (Bloomberg Law, September 30, 2024).
• Rebecca Santana, “Biden Administration Doubles Down on Tough Asylum Restrictions at Border” (Associated Press, Associated Press, September 30, 2024).
• Sandra Sanchez, “Dhs Increases Amount of Time Asylum Regulations at Southwest Border in Effect” (Border Report, September 30, 2024).
• “‘Cruel’: Biden Administration Toughens Asylum Restrictions at Us Border” (Al Jazeera, September 30, 2024).
• “Eeuu Consolida Restricciones al Asilo en la Frontera, a un Mes de las Elecciones Generales” (EFE, Efecto Cocuyo (Venezuela), September 30, 2024).

The UN Refugee Agency voiced “profound concern” about the tightened asylum regulation, which “severely curtails access to protection for people fleeing conflict, persecution, and violence, putting many refugees and asylum seekers in grave danger without a viable option for seeking safety.”

• Matthew Reynolds, “Unhcr Reiterates Concern About Us Asylum Regulations” (UN Refugee Agency, September 30, 2024).

CNN reported that Border Patrol was on track to apprehend about 54,000 migrants (1,800 per day) at the border during the month of September. That would be down slightly from 56,399 (1,819 per day) in July and 58,038 (1,872 per day) in August.

• Priscilla Alvarez, “Migrant Crossings at the Us’ Southern Border Drop Again Amid Campaign Year Scrutiny” (CNN, September 30, 2024).

A criminal organization in the border city of San Luis Rio Colorado, Sonora, Mexico—near Yuma, Arizona—placed 24 surveillance cameras on telephone poles, wiring them into power lines for electricity and into telephone lines for internet connectivity.

• “Surveillance Cameras Placed on Palm Trees by Drug Cartel “Falcons” in City on Border With Arizona, Mexico Authorities Say” (CBS News, September 30, 2024).

Migrants—some seeking or awaiting CBP One appointments—in Mexico’s southern border-zone city of Tapachula, Chiapas, participated in a procession organized by the local Catholic diocese. They called for protection from organized crime and faster asylum adjudication from the Mexican government’s Refugee Assistance Commission (COMAR).

• Jhonatan Gonzalez, “Migrantes Piden Mayor Seguridad a los Gobiernos Entrantes” (Milenio (Mexico), September 30, 2024).

Analyses and Feature Stories

In Border Patrol’s El Paso Sector, where agents have recovered the remains of a local record 175 migrants in fiscal 2024, USA Today’s Lauren Villagrán reported on the mental health toll that deaths and unsuccessful rescues take on personnel.

• Lauren Villagran, “Haunted by Migrant Deaths, Border Patrol Agents Face Mental Health Toll” (USA Today, October 1, 2024).

Analyses from the Washington Post and CBS News explained how the Trump campaign and other Republican politicians have been distorting and misinterpreting Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) data released in response to an inquiry from border-district Rep. Tony Gonzales (R-Texas). That data points to 13,099 immigrants with homicide convictions on ICE’s “non-detained” docket, which simply means that they are not in ICE’s custody though they may be imprisoned elsewhere.

The vast majority of these individuals did not cross the border during the Biden presidency. Still, Sen. Tom Cotton (R-Arkansas) told CBS’s Face the Nation that the Biden administration “released more than 13,000 convicted murderers who illegally entered this country.”

• Philip Bump, “The Right’s Newest False Outrage Centers on Misrepresented Federal Data” (The Washington Post, September 30, 2024).
• Mariana Alfaro, Nick Miroff, “How Trump Is Distorting Immigration and Crime Data in New Attacks on Harris” (The Washington Post, September 30, 2024).
• Camilo Montoya-Galvez, “Trump and Allies Mischaracterize Data on Immigrants With Criminal Convictions. Here’s Context on What the Numbers Actually Show.” (CBS News, September 30, 2024).

In recent days, Donald Trump’s “rhetoric about migrants has grown even darker and more foreboding,” wrote Mark Follman at Mother Jones. Migrants, he said at a Wisconsin rally, “are stone-cold killers. They’ll walk into your kitchen, they’ll cut your throat.”

• Mark Follman, “Trump Is Amplifying His Dangerous Hate Speech Against Migrants” (Mother Jones, September 30, 2024).

On the Right

• Nicole Russell, “Abbott Says Harris ‘Failed Miserably’ on Border Crisis. He’s Fixing It Instead.” (USA Today, October 1, 2024).
• Adam Bennett, “‘Operation Lone Star Has Been Successful’ | Texas Dps Director, Border Czar Defend Program, Tout Drop in Illegal Crossings” (KVUE (Austin Texas), September 30, 2024).

Get daily links in your email

Developments

Vice President Kamala Harris is to pay her first visit to the U.S.-Mexico border since becoming the Democratic candidate for president. She will be in Douglas, Arizona, today, where she is scheduled to meet with CBP personnel at the port of entry and give a campaign speech.

Recent polls have shown Harris narrowly trailing Republican opponent Donald Trump in Arizona, a “battleground state” where competition for electoral votes is tight.

An unnamed senior campaign official told The Hill that Harris plans to “reject the false choice between securing the border and creating an immigration system that is safe, orderly and humane—arguing we must do both to protect our country’s security and enduring legacy as a nation of immigrants.”

Media reports indicate that Harris plans to attack Donald Trump for urging Republican members of Congress to defeat a compromise border-security bill that failed in the Senate in February. Harris will repeat a promise to sign a reintroduced “Border Act” if it reaches her desk. That bill included some common-sense border and migration provisions, like adding capacity at ports of entry and in the asylum system. But it also included harder-line measures like increasing detention beds and denying much access to asylum during busy periods.

A version of the asylum-denial provision is now in place, pending court challenges, under an early-June Biden administration proclamation and rule.

• Jonathan J. Cooper, Will Weissert, “Harris Heads to the Us-Mexico Border to Try to Show That Her Record Is More Than Trump Criticisms” (Associated Press, Associated Press, September 27, 2024).
• Jazmine Ulloa, Kellen Browning, Nicholas Nehamas, “Harris Heads to the Border, Trying to Project Toughness Against Trump” (The New York Times, September 27, 2024).
• Joey Garrison, Rebecca Morin, “Harris Heads to Southern Border in Arizona — Where She’s Losing Ground to Trump” (USA Today, September 27, 2024).
• Alex Gangitano, “Harris Border Visit to Focus on Curbing Fentanyl Flow, Boosting Resources for Border Agents” (The Hill, September 27, 2024).
• Fritz Farrow, Gabriella Abdul-Hakim, Will Mcduffie, “Harris to Criticize Trump in Her 1st Visit to Border in More Than 3 Years” (ABC News, September 27, 2024).
• Niels Lesniewski, “Harris Campaign Seeks to Turn Tables on Trump on Border Security” (Roll Call, September 27, 2024).
• Nidia Cavazos, “Harris to Call for Tougher Security Measures in First Trip to Southern Border as Nominee” (CBS News, September 27, 2024).
• Priscilla Alvarez, “Harris Heads to the Us Southern Border, Looking to Close a Polling Gap With Trump” (CNN, September 27, 2024).
• Mia Osmonbekov, “Kamala Harris Heads to Douglas to Blunt Attacks Over Border Security” (Cronkite News, September 26, 2024).
• Mary Ann Akers, “Kamala Harris Shoves the Migrant Border Crisis in Trump’s Face” (The Daily Beast, September 27, 2024).
• Stephanie Murray, “5 Questions Ahead of Kamala Harris’ Trip to the Arizona Border” (The Arizona Republic, September 26, 2024).
• Avery Lotz, “Harris to Visit U.S.-Mexico Border to Tout Toughness on Immigration” (Axios, September 26, 2024).
• Paul Steinhauser, “Harris Heads to Southern Border Looking to Flip Script on Immigration Criticisms” (Fox News, September 27, 2024).
• Dw Gibson, “Bipartisan Border Bill Would Help the Economy, Bring Migrants Into the Workforce” (The Hill, September 26, 2024).

“Anything she says tomorrow, you know is a fraud because she was the worst in history at protecting our country,” Trump said in remarks yesterday in New York. “She should go back to the White House and tell the president to close the border.” The New York Times noted that after beginning with about 10 minutes of border content, Trump “appeared to grow bored” with his prepared remarks and veered off into other topics.

• Maggie Haberman, Michael Gold, “Mcdonald’s, Pelosi, Debate Moderators: Trump Speech on Border Veers Off Course” (The New York Times, September 26, 2024).

As early as Monday, CBS News and the New York Times revealed, the Biden administration plans to announce a toughening of its June rule banning asylum between border ports of entry at busy times.

The rule shuts down asylum access for those who cross the border without inspection whenever Border Patrol apprehensions, not counting unaccompanied children from non-contiguous countries, average over 2,500 people per day for a week. It would restore asylum access after a weekly average drops below 1,500 per day, not counting unaccompanied children from non-contiguous countries. (In August, it was about 1,870 per day.)

The administration’s likely adjustments would put a restoration of asylum further out of reach. Border Patrol apprehensions would have to fall below an average of 1,500 per day for 4 weeks—not 1 week—and unaccompanied children would count toward the total.

• Camilo Montoya-Galvez, “Biden Moving Forward With Plan to Cement Asylum Restrictions at U.S.-Mexico Border” (CBS News, September 26, 2024).
• Hamed Aleaziz, “Biden Administration Set to Make Asylum Limits More Permanent” (The New York Times, September 26, 2024).

Texas’s attorney-general, Ken Paxton (R), is further broadening his legal campaign against non-profits in the state that serve migrants. Paxton has opened an investigation of the El Paso-based Las Americas Immigrant Advocacy Center, which represents asylum seekers and advocates for migrants’ rights. That makes at least five migrants rights defense organizations or shelters targeted this year.

Las Americas and the Texas Civil Rights Project (TCRP) responded yesterday with a federal civil rights lawsuit seeking a preliminary injunction to block Paxton. “We’re witnessing a disturbing pattern in Texas in which immigrant legal services and voting rights are under a coordinated siege by the Attorney General under the guise of protecting voter integrity,” said TCRP’s Rochelle Garza.

• “Las Americas Responds to Tx Attorney General’s Baseless Investigation Against the Work of Welcome” (Las Americas Immigrant Advocacy Center, September 26, 2024).
• Vianna Davila, “Attorney General Ken Paxton Targets el Paso Nonprofit That Offers Legal Services to Migrants” (Texas Tribune and ProPublica, The Texas Tribune, September 26, 2024).
• Robert Moore, “Texas Ag Paxton Seeks Records From el Paso Legal Assistance Nonprofit on Biden Administration Immigration Policies, Lawsuit Says” (El Paso Matters, September 26, 2024).

The Washington Post noted that Rep. Colin Allred (D-Texas), the Democratic challenger to ultraconservative Sen. Ted Cruz’s (R-Texas) re-election bid, has, like Harris, pivoted to tougher talk on the border and migration.

• Patrick Svitek, “Democratic Senate Candidate in Texas Tries to Flip the Script on the Border” (The Washington Post, September 26, 2024).

In the Darién Gap, migrants from Venezuela interviewed by Agénce France Presse say that they are migrating out of fear amid increased repression after authorities declared that the nation’s leader, Nicolás Maduro, won re-election on July 28. The Venezuelan government provided no proof to back up this claim.

• “Venezolanos en el Darien Dicen Que Migran por «Miedo» Tras Reeleccion de Maduro” (Agence France Presse, Nicaragua Investiga, September 26, 2024).

Border Patrol agents found 72 migrants whom smugglers were keeping in a storage shed in south El Paso.

• Fernie Ortiz, “72 Migrants Found in Storage Shed, Border Patrol Says” (Border Report, September 26, 2024).

Analyses and Feature Stories

Human Rights Watch denounced disturbing recent incidents in Eagle Pass, Texas: Texas National Guard personnel continue to fire pepper-spray projectiles at migrants, including families with children, attempting to cross the Rio Grande. Soldiers are using force even though their targets are unarmed, posing no threat, and separated from them by concertina-wire barriers.

• Texas National Guard Firing Pepper Spray Projectiles at Migrants (Human Rights Watch, Wednesday, September 25, 2024).
• Sandra Sanchez, “Texas National Guard Fires Pepper Balls at Migrants Crossing Border, Groups Says” (Border Report, September 26, 2024).

The New York Review of Books covered two recent volumes about the border and migration, John Washington’s The Case for Open Borders and Lauren Markham’s A Map of Future Ruins: On Borders and Belonging.

• Colin Thubron, “The Artificiality of Nations” (The New York Review of Books, October 17, 2024).

“Immigration is a blessing the U.S. needs to nurture and manage,” wrote Andrés Marínez of Arizona State University at Time. “But our shared politicized narratives on the subject are veering so dangerously off course that a serious contender for the presidency can pass off talk of deporting millions of hardworking immigrants as a sensible proposal.”

• Andres Martinez, “What Harris and Trump Get Wrong About the Border” (Arizona State University, Time, September 26, 2024).

Of migrants in their care shortly after arriving at the border in Arizona, Doctors Without Borders noted that most are suffering stress that is “not post-traumatic. They are still in a kind of traumatic reaction, which is a physical and mental state. And they should be. They are hyper alert, and ready to run at any moment after what many of them have gone through.”

• “How MSF Provides Mental Health Care for Migrants and Asylum Seekers at the Us-Mexico Border” (Doctors Without Borders, September 26, 2024).

Regardless of the election outcome, “the issue of immigration seems set to remain a political cudgel,” Aimee Santillán of the El Paso-based Hope Border Institute told the National Catholic Reporter.

• Kimberley Heatherington, “Advocates for Migrants, Refugees See Challenging Times Ahead No Matter the Election Outcome” (National Catholic Reporter, September 26, 2024).

On the Right

• Jennie Taer, “Arizona Rancher Calls Out Kamala Harris for Last-Minute Border Trip, Says She ‘Encouraged Illegal Immigration’” (The New York Post, September 27, 2024).

Get daily links in your email

Note: staff are likely to be testifying in a congressional hearing on Wednesday 25. Preparation for that event will prevent us from posting daily updates again until Friday 27, and we will be unable to produce a Weekly Border Update.

Developments

Between June 5 (when the Biden administration’s restrictive asylum rule went into effect) and September 10, the U.S. government has returned “more than 131,000 individuals to more than 140 countries,” Luis Miranda, the Principal Deputy Assistant Homeland Security Secretary for Communications, told the Venezuelan daily Tal Cual.

• Luna Perdomo, “Cruce Ilegal de Venezolanos a Eeuu se Redujo en 90% en los Ultimos Meses” (Tal Cual (Venezuela), September 22, 2024).

Panama sent two more deportation flights carrying migrants from the Darién Gap back to their countries of origin: one to Colombia on September 19 and one to Ecuador on September 20. Since the beginning of August, pointed out Thomas Cartwright of Witness at the Border, Panama has run 11 flights, most with U.S. support, that have deported 441 people. The Panamanian daily La Prensa counted 433 people, and a total cost of $900,000 for the 11 flights. That is $2,079 per deported person.

• “Thcartwright @Thcartwright on Twitter” (Twitter, September 21, 2024).
• Henry Cardenas P., “Panama Ha Deportado 433 Migrantes en un Mes Como Parte del Acuerdo Con Estados Unidos” (La Prensa (Panama), September 20, 2024).

A front page New York Times story examined the presence of the Tren de Aragua, a Venezuelan organized crime gang that may be gaining a toehold in parts of the United States. In the New York area, law enforcement sources told the Times that they first saw signs of the group’s presence in January 2024. Still, “migrants living in city shelters said they had not noticed the gang’s influence there.”

• Chelsia Rose Marcius, Luis Ferre-Sadurni, “Venezuelan Gang’s Path to U.S. Stokes Fear, Crime and Border Politics” (The New York Times, September 23, 2024).

A sensationalistic New York Post story claimed that the Tren de Aragua has turned New York City shelters into “hubs” for their criminal activities.

• Joe Marino, Jorge Fitz-Gibbon, “How Bloodthirsty Venezuelan Gang Tren de Aragua Used Nyc Migrant Shelters to Build a Criminal Empire: ‘Hiding in Plain Sight’” (The New York Post, September 22, 2024).

At the Otay Mesa port of entry east of San Diego on September 18, a CBP officer shot and wounded a man who was advancing while holding a screwdriver and ignoring commands to drop the tool.

• Elizabeth Ireland, “Man Wielding Screwdriver Shot by Cbp Officer at Otay Mesa Port of Entry” (Times of San Diego, September 20, 2024).

Border Patrol agents and Customs and Border Protection (CBP) officers told NewsNation of recent cases of migrant smugglers sedating children, usually with over-the-counter medications, when they take them across the border.

• Jorge Ventura, “Human Traffickers Drugging Kids Crossing Southern Border: Officials” (NewsNation, September 22, 2024).

The chief of Border Patrol’s El Centro Sector tweeted that a large fentanyl seizure from a vehicle in the neighboring San Diego Sector was an example of what the agency could do “when agents aren’t processing coached asylum claims.”

• “Usbp Chief Patrol Agent Gregory K. Bovino @Usbpchiefelc on Twitter” (Twitter, September 21, 2024).

Analyses and Feature Stories

CBS News’s 60 Minutes program covered trafficking in fentanyl, “the worst drug crisis in U.S. history.” Acting CBP Commissioner Troy Miller recalled that about 90 percent of fentanyl crossing into the United States from Mexico comes in passenger vehicles. It is not brought by undocumented migrants; in fact, two-thirds of those arrested for smuggling the drug are U.S. citizens.

• Aliza Chasan, Bill Whitaker, Graham Messick, Jack Weingart, Scott Higham, “What’s Fueling the Fentanyl Crisis Is “Not a Whodunit,” But “There’s So Much More That Needs to Be Done,” Dea Leader Says” (CBS News, September 22, 2024).

An El País analysis of the Trump campaign’s promise to carry out a “mass deportation” program found that it could cost between $265 billion and $481 billion to carry out. By removing 4.5 percent of the U.S. workforce, it estimates, the promised removal program would slow U.S. GDP growth by more than 9 percentage points while increasing inflation.

• Nicholas Dale Leal, “The Cost of Trump’s Mass Deportation Plan: More Than 10 Times Immigration’s Budget and a Possible Recession” (El Pais (Spain), September 23, 2024).

An Associated Press analysis of “mass deportation” looked at the legal authorities, like the 1798 Alien Enemies Act, that a re-elected President Trump might use to employ soldiers to remove both undocumented migrants and those whose status his administration would revoke.

• Elliot Spagat, “Trump’s Goal of Mass Deportations Fell Short. But He Has New Plans for a Second Term” (Associated Press, Associated Press, September 22, 2024).

“Trump’s bald embrace of xenophobia” in the election campaign leads to the discouraging conclusion that “overtly racist appeals,” well beyond euphemisms, do not harm a candidate’s standing in 2024, concluded an analysis of the current electoral moment by Caitlin Dickerson at the Atlantic.

• Caitlin Dickerson, “Lies About Immigration Help No One” (The Atlantic, September 21, 2024).

Border Report’s Sandra Sanchez accompanied volunteers training, with Texas State University’s Operation Identification, to identify the remains of migrants who died near the border in Texas.

• Sandra Sanchez, “Students, Volunteers Help Fingerprint Migrant Remains With Hopes of Identifying Them” (Border Report, September 22, 2024).

Reporting from El Paso’s outskirts, where migrant deaths have been surging, Morgan Lee of the Associated Press found that while the border and migration are big election issues, residents of this and other border zones tend to hold a “nuanced view” and are dissatisfied with perceived inaction from Washington.

• Morgan Lee, “The Politics of Immigration Play Differently Along the Us-Mexico Border” (Associated Press, Associated Press, September 20, 2024).

At the Atlantic, Paola Ramos profiled Pedro Antonio Agüero, a Mexican-American social media influencer from El Paso who calls himself “Conservative Anthony” and “stalks and confronts people he suspects of being migrants while livestreaming the encounters on his website.”

• Paola Ramos, “On the Road With a Latino Border Vigilante” (The Atlantic, September 23, 2024).

On the Right

• Nolan Rappaport, “Mexico, Not Biden, Deserves Credit for the Reduction in Illegal Border Crossings” (The Hill, September 23, 2024).
• Christina Coulter, “Families in Swing State Afraid to Let Kids Play Outside After Venezuelan Migrant Attacks Mom, Child: Lawmaker” (Fox News, September 23, 2024).
• Bethany Blankley, “Texas Dps Sounds Alarm on ‘Special Interest Aliens’ Illegally Entering From Mexico” (The Center Square, The Washington Examiner, September 22, 2024).
• Bethany Blankley, “Fact Check: Bad Neighbor? New Mexico Governor Criticizes Texas for Securing Her Border” (The Center Square, September 20, 2024).

Get daily links in your email

Developments

CBS News obtained unpublished post-2022 Border Patrol data about the number of remains of deceased migrants that the agency has recovered along the U.S.-Mexico border. “The number of migrant deaths recorded by Border Patrol increased to 568 in fiscal year 2021 and then soared to nearly 900 [890] in fiscal year 2022—an all-time high. In fiscal years 2023 and 2024, Border Patrol recorded 704 and 560 migrant deaths respectively.”

• Camilo Montoya-Galvez, Justo Robles, Suvro Banerji, “Finding Missing Migrants Along the U.S.-Mexico Border, the World’s Deadliest Land Migration Route” (CBS News, September 19, 2024).

Chris Magnus, a former Tucson police chief who headed Customs and Border Protection (CBP) for about a year early in the Biden administration, told Arizona Luminaria that he was troubled by a recent incident in Arizona, when Border Patrol failed to assist a man who fell from the wall, leaving him lying on the Mexican side of the barrier with a compound fracture. The incident, Magnus said, “speaks to a more significant cultural problem that’s not unique to the Border Patrol but deeply troubling anywhere in law enforcement when those sworn to protect forget that protecting lives must be their top priority regardless of politics, bureaucracy, burn-out, or fear of repercussions.”

• John Washington, “Border Patrol’s Refusal to Rescue an Injured Man by Cutting the Wall Shows a Larger “Cultural Problem,” Former Cbp Commissioner Says” (Arizona Luminaria, September 19, 2024).

After more than a week of baseless attacks on a Haitian migrant population in Ohio, the Trump-Vance campaign may shift focus to Venezuelan migrants in Colorado. Colorado Public Radio reported that Donald Trump plans to visit Aurora, a Denver suburb where—despite emphatic local police and government denials—rumors spread that Venezuela’s “Tren de Aragua” organized-crime group had taken control of an apartment complex.

• Caitlyn Kim, “Trump Says He’s Coming to Aurora, Doubles Down on Claims of Venezuelan Gang Violence” (Colorado Public Radio, September 19, 2024).

New Mexico Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham (D) criticized Gov. Greg Abbott (R) of neighboring border state Texas for ordering National Guard troops to lay barbed wire along the borderline between the states. Texas’s state government billed the move as a measure to keep migrants who cross into New Mexico from entering Texas. “Gov. Abbott seems to be pushing to make Texas its own country without regard for his neighbors,” Lujan Grisham said.

• Fallon Fischer, “New Mexico’s Governor Blasts Texas for Placing Razor Wire on Border Between Their States” (Valley Central, September 19, 2024).

At this moment of reduced migration, Texas’s state government is planning to close and consolidate some of its police and military deployment along the border. “Officials with the State National Guard revealed that two of the four operation base camps, one in Laredo and one north of Eagle Pass, will be shut down,” an Austin television station reported. “A base camp near Del Rio is also being downsized.” Some will be reassigned to a large base that Texas recently built near Eagle Pass.

• Rudy Koski, “Texas Border Deployment Going Through ‘Realignment’: Officials” (FOX 7 (Austin Texas), September 19, 2024).

“An unidentified foreign national” punched and bit a Border Patrol agent in an altercation on Mount Cristo Rey, on the western edge of El Paso, Border Report reported. Mexican police “have three people in custody.”

• Julian Resendiz, “Border Patrol Agent Bitten in Face During Assault on Mount Cristo Rey” (Border Report, September 19, 2024).

Three El Paso and New Mexico-area nonprofits petitioned for a writ of habeas corpus for four Venezuelan citizens who have been held for nearly a year at the Otero Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) facility in Chaparral, New Mexico. Venezuela’s government is refusing to allow deportation flights, and the detained people have voiced fear of deportation into Mexico.

• Julian Resendiz, “Venezuelan Migrants Sue for Release After Nearly a Year at Ice Detention Center” (Border Report, September 19, 2024).

Analyses and Feature Stories

Reporting from Sunland Park, New Mexico, an area near El Paso where migrant deaths are surging, Associated Press reporter Morgan Lee found that Democrats representing border districts “are promoting border enforcement as seldom before.”

• Morgan Lee, “The Politics of Immigration Play Differently Along the Us-Mexico Border” (Associated Press, Associated Press, September 20, 2024).

Former Biden National Security Council official Katie Tobin published an article for the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace upholding the 2022 Los Angeles Declaration on Migration and Protection, which “largely” continues to guide many Western Hemisphere nations’ commitments to improve integration of migrants and coordination of migration policies. The article praises increased cooperation, increased reparations, and the U.S.-backed “Safe Mobility Office” initiative. It laments a lack of economic investment, some countries’ “lack of political will,” and persistent migration through the Darién Gap.

• Katie Tobin, “The los Angeles Declaration Continues to Shape the Regional and Global Migration Response” (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, September 19, 2024).

Dr. Belén Ramírez of Doctors Without Borders published an account of the organization’s work at an aid camp in Arizona where volunteers provide humanitarian assistance to asylum seekers waiting in the desert to turn themselves in to Border Patrol. Many are now coming from countries in Asia and Africa, which presents new language barriers.

• Dr. Belen Ramirez, “48 Hours at the Us-Mexico Border” (Doctors Without Borders, September 19, 2024).

An analysis by photojournalist Adri Salido at the Guardian, reported from Guatemala, pointed to temporary work programs as a solution to reduce the number of people who make the dangerous journey to the U.S.-Mexico border.

• Adri Salido, “Is Circular Migration a Solution to the Crisis at the Us Border? Guatemala Provides a Clue” (The Guardian (Uk), September 19, 2024).

On the Right

• Adam Shaw, “Ex-Border Patrol Chief Rips Biden Admin for Allegedly Suppressing Info on Migrants With Potential Terror Ties” (Fox News, September 19, 2024).

Get daily links in your email

Developments

Vice President Kamala Harris, the Democratic presidential nominee, included a few paragraphs about the border and migration in remarks given yesterday to the Congressional Hispanic Caucus Institute. Without mentioning specifics or referring to the Biden administration’s current imposition of asylum restrictions, Harris called for immigration reform, protection for “DREAMers,” an “earned pathway to citizenship” and ensuring that “our border is secure.”

Harris attacked Donald Trump for presiding over family separations and for his campaign’s plan to carry out mass deportations if elected. “Imagine what that would look like and what that would be. How is that going to happen? Massive raids? Massive detention camps? What are they talking about?”

• “Remarks by Vice President Harris at the Congressional Hispanic Caucus Institute’s 47th Annual Leadership Conference” (The White House, September 18, 2024).
• Zolan Kanno-Youngs, “Harris Warns of Mass Deportations and Detention Camps if Trump Is Elected” (The New York Times, September 18, 2024).
• Sabrina Rodriguez, “Harris Urges Latino Leaders to Help Mobilize Key Voting Bloc” (The Washington Post, September 18, 2024).

A Scripps News/Ipsos poll found that 39 percent of U.S. respondents, and 47 percent of Arizona respondents, ranked “immigration” second, after “inflation,” as one of the most important issues facing the United States.

• Three in five said they “are closely following news around the immigration situation at the U.S.-Mexico border.”
• 54 percent of respondents said they favored mass deportation of undocumented immigrants, though 68 percent favored a pathway to citizenship for DREAMers: undocumented immigrants who were brought to the United States as children.
• By a margin of 44 to 34 percent, respondents voiced a view that Donald Trump would “do a better job handling immigration.”

• Mallory Newall, “Securing the Border Is Seen as the Top Immigration Priority” (Ipsos, September 18, 2024).
• Elizabeth Crisp, “54 Percent of Americans Back Mass Deportation of Immigrants: Poll” (The Hill, September 18, 2024).

The Republican-majority House of Representatives’ Homeland Security Committee held a hearing yesterday entitled “A Country Without Borders: How Biden-Harris’ Open-Borders Policies Have Undermined Our Safety and Security.” Witnesses at the highly contentious proceedings included a former Border Patrol sector chief; a Republican member of San Diego County’s Board of Supervisors; the mother of a woman allegedly raped and murdered by a man from El Salvador; and the sheriff of Santa Cruz County, Arizona, which includes Nogales.

• “A Country Without Borders: How Biden-Harris’ Open-Borders Policies Have Undermined Our Safety and Security” (House of Representatives Committee on Homeland Security, September 18, 2024).
• Alexandra Mendoza, “Supervisor Desmond, Former San Diego Border Patrol Chief Testify at House Hearing” (The San Diego Union-Tribune, September 18, 2024).
• Anna Giaritelli, “Former Senior Border Patrol Agent Alleges Biden-Harris Had Him Hide Border Crisis” (The Washington Examiner, September 18, 2024).
• Louis Casiano, “Sheriff Calls the Border Wall ‘Racist’ While Seated Next to Mom of Woman Allegedly Killed by Illegal Migrant” (Fox News, September 18, 2024).

By a vote of 266-158, the House of Representatives passed the “Violence Against Women by Illegal Aliens Act,” a Republican-led bill that makes deportable any non-citizen convicted of “a crime of domestic violence or a sex offense.” Advocates like the Tahirih Justice Center worried that the bill could jeopardize immigrant victims of those crimes: “Abusers who better understand the U.S. language and laws can prevent victims from accessing safety by threatening to expose immigrant victims to the police, ICE, and the deportation machine.”

• “Urge Your Representative in Congress to Oppose h.r. 7909 & Protect Immigrant Survivors!” (Tahirih Justice Center, September 18, 2024).

The House’s Republican majority failed to muster enough votes to pass a budget measure to keep the U.S. government open after fiscal year 2024 ends on September 30. The bill had language attached to it requiring states to demand that all who register to vote provide proof of citizenship. Next steps for avoiding a government shutdown are currently unclear.

• Carl Hulse, “House Defeats Johnson’s Spending Plan With Shutdown Looming” (The New York Times, September 18, 2024).

Republican and Democratic legislators in both houses of Congress introduced the “Enhancing Southbound Inspections to Combat Cartels Act,” legislation that would increase inspections of outbound traffic from the United States to Mexico, seeking to combat flows principally of firearms and bulk cash.

• Rep. Abigail Spanberger (D-Virginia), “Spanberger, Crenshaw Lead Bipartisan Effort to Combat Firearms & Cash Smuggling by Cartels at Southern Border” (U.S. House of Representatives, September 18, 2024).

Citing official figures, a UNHCR update reported that 272,168 people entered Honduras irregularly, most with the intention of migrating to the United States, during January-July 2024. Because “not all persons on the move who enter Honduras irregularly register” with Honduran authorities, UNHCR estimated that 340,000 people transited the country during those 7 months.

Panama reported a much smaller number (221,582) of people transiting the Darién Gap region during January-July 2024. Much of the difference is citizens of Nicaragua who pass through Honduras, plus citizens of other countries who avoid the Darién passage by flying to Nicaragua, taking advantage of the country’s less-restrictive visa policies.

• “Honduras – Operational Update – July 2024” (UN Refugee Agency, September 18, 2024).

October will mark two years since the Biden administration established a humanitarian parole program for citizens from Venezuela, and January will mark two years since that program expanded to include citizens of Cuba, Haiti, and Nicaragua. As the parole status expires after two years, Department of Homeland Security (DHS) officials told Univisión that its beneficiaries need to adjust their immigration status before their deadlines.

• Jorge Cancino, “Inmigrantes Con ‘Parole Humanitario’ Que No Cambien su Estatus Deberan Salir de Eeuu o Seran Deportados” (Univision, September 18, 2024).

Analyses and Feature Stories

Recently published analyses of the Trump-Vance campaign’s unfounded and racist attacks on Haitian migrants living and working legally in Springfield, Ohio included an in-depth investigation of the attacks’ origin at the Wall Street Journal; an Atlantic essay by Adam Serwer; a Washington Post column by Edwidge Danticat; an Isaac Chotiner interview at the New Yorker with white-supremacism expert Kathleen Belew; and a post to the American Council’s Immigration Impact site by Aaron Reichlin-Melnick.

• Kris Maher, Tawnell D. Hobbs, Valerie Bauerlein, “How the Trump Campaign Ran With Rumors About Pet-Eating Migrants—After Being Told They Weren’t True” (The Wall Street Journal, September 18, 2024).
• Adam Serwer, “The Real Reason Trump and Vance Are Spreading Lies About Haitians” (The Atlantic, September 18, 2024).
• Edwidge Danticat, “Haitian Americans Again Must Proclaim Our Humanity” (The Washington Post, September 18, 2024).
• Isaac Chotiner, “The Historical Precedents to Trump’s Attacks on Haitian Immigrants” (The New Yorker, September 18, 2024).
• Aaron Reichlin-Melnick, “Immigrants Are Making Ohio Great. Let’s Talk About That.” (Immigration Impact, American Immigration Council, September 17, 2024).

A report from the American Civil Liberties Union and the ACLU of Texas warned that federal and state immigration checkpoints combine with a state-level abortion ban to make it impossible for undocumented migrants to leave Texas to obtain reproductive health services. CBP and Border Patrol maintain 19 federal checkpoints in the state of Texas, making road travel difficult for those without documentation.

• “Trapped in Texas: How Federal – and Now State – Immigration Enforcement Traps People Trying to Escape Texas’ Abortion Ban” (American Civil Liberties Union, September 18, 2024).

NPR investigated the deployment of National Guard troops from Iowa, Missouri, and Nebraska to the U.S.-Mexico border as part of Texas Governor Greg Abbott’s (R) controversial “Operation Lone Star.” The three non-border, Republican-governed states have spent a combined $7.1 million to send troops to the border.

• Kallie Cox, “Midwest States Far From U.S.-Mexico Border Have Spent Millions to Send Troops There” (KCUR, NPR, September 18, 2024).

The El Paso-based Border Network for Human Rights and the Texas Civil Rights Project held a news conference to report on numerous recent examples of Texas National Guard soldiers, working in support of Operation Lone Star, physically and verbally abusing migrants at the borderline. (WOLA published a September 13 commentary documenting similar credible allegations.)

• Julian Resendiz, “Texas Guard Verbally, Physically Abusing Asylum-Seekers at Border, Group Says” (Border Report, September 18, 2024).

Interviewed by Newsweek, the Cato Institute’s David Bier disputed the Trump campaign’s wildly inflated claim that 20 million migrants have been allowed into the United States during the Biden presidency.

• Dan Gooding, “Trump’s Illegal Border Numbers ‘Not Based in Reality’: Immigration Expert” (Newsweek, September 18, 2024).

Get daily links in your email

Developments

In an article about Texas’s state government laying razor wire down along the state border with New Mexico, Border Report revealed Border Patrol’s latest count of migrant deaths in its El Paso Sector, which includes far west Texas and New Mexico: 171 remains recovered in fiscal 2024 (since October). That is up sharply from 149 in 2023, 71 in 2022, and 39 in 2021.

• Julian Resendiz, “Texas Doubles Down on Razor Wire, Fencing Facing New Mexico” (Border Report, September 17, 2024).

A letter from over 75 organizations, organized by the El Paso-based Hope Border Institute, calls for improvements to the CBP One app‘s feature allowing asylum seekers to make appointments at border ports of entry. These include increasing the number of appointments, and improving protections for applicants who must spend many months in Mexico awaiting appointments. Some miss those appointments because they’ve been kidnapped by criminal organizations.

• “Letter From Over 75 Organizations and Congregations Regarding Cbp One” (Hope Border Institute, September 17, 2024).

A response to a Newsweek Freedom of Information Act request revealed that 211 CBP personnel are under investigation for serious misconduct. Accusations include “17 alleged cases of domestic violence, 11 cases of sexual assault, and 10 cases of smuggling migrants across the border,” along with 11 cases of physically abusing a detainee, and 13 cases of association with criminal gangs.

• Billal Rahman, “Exclusive: Border Agents Investigated for Smuggling, Sex Assault and Bribes” (Newsweek, September 18, 2024).

Charities that help migrants in Nogales, Arizona, were approached by an organization called “My Bright Horizon” that left brochures and offers to help migrants with transportation and lodging. At the Border Chronicle, Melissa del Bosque revealed that the group is actually “the latest phase of Florida governor Ron DeSantis’s [R] controversial flight program to transport migrants into Democratic-led states.”

• Melissa del Bosque, “Florida Governor’s Controversial ‘Migrant Relocation’ Program Targets Arizona” (The Border Chronicle, September 16, 2024).

The U.S. Senate passed the “Southern Border Transparency Act,” which requires the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) to report in more detail about paroles and releases of migrants. (DHS reporting on migrant custody and transfers has in fact improved since this bill was introduced in late 2023.) It is not clear whether this bill will move in the House of Representatives.

• “Ellen M. Gilmer @Ellengilmer on Twitter” (Twitter, September 17, 2024).

Analyses and Feature Stories

Of 1.8 million asylum seekers, refugees and other migrants who entered the United States in 2023—both at the border and elsewhere—12 percent settled in U.S. states considered “swing” or “battleground” states for the 2024 election, according to a Bloomberg analysis. Of these, 72 percent listed addresses in those states in counties that voted for Joe Biden in 2020.

• Shawn Donnan, “How Immigration Is Playing Out in 2024 Battleground States” (Bloomberg, September 17, 2024).

At Mother Jones, Isabel Dias noted Republican candidate Donald Trump’s use of the term “remigration” instead of “deportation” in a recent post to his social network. “The word stands in for a policy that entails the forced repatriation or mass expulsion of non–ethnically European immigrants and their descendants, regardless of citizenship.”

• Isabela Dias, “Trump Just Introduced a New, Dangerous Immigration Proposal” (Mother Jones, September 17, 2024).

Republican candidates’ racist comments about Haitian migrants in Springfield, Ohio drew a response from Haitian-American author and professor Roxane Gay at the New Yorker. “Every five years or so, there is a renewed effort to lodge ridiculous, deeply racist and xenophobic accusations against Haitian people… Trump and Vance, with their comments, have brought a renewed and naked contempt for Haitians into contemporary American discourse.”

• Roxane Gay, “The Haitian Question” (The New Yorker, September 17, 2024).

A report from the Niskanen Center looked at the causes of increased migration of citizens of India to the United States. They include religious persecution, political instability in some regions, and economic dislocations. Recently more Indian migrants have been apprehended at the border with Canada than at the border with Mexico. Routes often begin in El Salvador (which now charges a large fee for visas) and Nicaragua, but increasingly begin in Bolivia, which requires overland travel through the Darién Gap.

• Gil Guerra, Sneha Puri, “Indian Migrants at the U.S. Border: What the Data Reveals” (Niskanen Center, September 16, 2024).

“I wish this entire year at the border was just a movie. I wish it was an improbable fiction that leaders from both major political parties are competing to see who can be the cruelest,” wrote Adriana Jasso, who spent a year working with asylum seekers at the border wall with American Friends Service Committee, at the San Diego Union-Tribune.

• Adriana Jasso, “Opinion: I Spent a Year at the Border Wall. Here’s What I Wish Jd Vance Learned.” (American Friends Service Committee, The San Diego Union-Tribune, September 17, 2024).

The Texas Tribune published a brief overview of the Tren de Aragua, a Venezuelan organized-crime group that Texas Gov. Greg Abbott (R) designated this week as a “terrorist organization.”

• Juan Salinas Ii, Pooja Salhotra, “What You Need to Know About the Venezuelan Gang That Texas Is Targeting” (The Texas Tribune, September 18, 2024).

On the Right

• Jennie Taer, Josh Christenson, “Homeland Security Boss Alejandro Mayorkas ‘Intentionally’ Opened Southern Border: Ex-Biden Border Patrol Chief” (The New York Post, September 17, 2024).

Get daily links in your email

Developments

Customs and Border Protection (CBP) released data about migration and enforcement at the U.S.-Mexico border through August.

• Last month, Border Patrol apprehended 58,038 people at the border. That is up slightly from July (56,399), but still the second-fewest since September 2020. It was the first time since February that Border Patrol’s apprehensions increased over the previous month. This may be a sign that the drop in migration at the border has “bottomed out” following a beginning-of-year crackdown in Mexico and a sweeping June Biden administration asylum-access restriction.
• As it strictly enforced the Biden administration’s June 2024 asylum restriction rule, Border Patrol released fewer people with “notices to appear” (9,936) than in any month since February 2021.
• Border Patrol’s fiscal year 2024 migrant apprehensions are on track to be 21 percent fewer than last year’s.
• An additional 49,465 people were able to enter custody at ports of entry (official border crossings). About 44,700 of that total were people who had made appointments using the CBP One app. CBP continues to allow about 1,450 CBP One appointments per day; the monthly port-of-entry total has changed little since June 2023.
• Combining Border Patrol and ports of entry, the nationalities most frequently encountered in August were citizens of Mexico (37,601), Venezuela (15,214), Cuba (10,423), Guatemala (7,099), and Honduras (6,943). Nearly all encounters with Cubans and Venezuelans took place at ports of entry.
• Of the nine sectors into which Border Patrol divides the border, San Diego, California (14,436) measured the most migrant apprehensions. El Paso, Texas-New Mexico (13,282) was in second place; it was last in the “top two” in April 2023. Tucson, Arizona (11,922) was third.
• Combining Border Patrol and ports of entry, 34 percent (36,016) of August’s migrant encounters were with members of family units, and 7 percent (7,130) were unaccompanied children. 32 percent of families and 35 percent of unaccompanied children were Mexican.
• CBP has seized 18,981 pounds of fentanyl at the border during the first 11 months of fiscal year 2024. For the first time since fentanyl first appeared in the mid-2010s, border seizures of the drug are almost certain to be fewer than they were in the year before (26,719 pounds in 2023). Fiscal 2024’s fentanyl seizures are on pace to be 23 percent fewer than in 2023.
• As in previous years, 88 percent of fentanyl has been seized at ports of entry, and another 5 percent at Border Patrol’s interior vehicle checkpoints.

• “Cbp Releases August 2024 Monthly Update” (U.S. Customs and Border Protection, September 16, 2024).
• “Arrests for Illegal Border Crossings Jump 3% in August, Suggesting Decline May Be Bottoming Out” (Associated Press, Associated Press, September 16, 2024).
• Priscilla Alvarez, “Biden Administration Says Number of Illegal Border Crossings Has Drastically Fallen as Trump Seizes on Immigration” (CNN, September 16, 2024).
• Kierra Frazier, “Activity Along the Southern Border Returns to Trump-Era Levels” (Politico, September 16, 2024).

Asylum seekers interviewed by EFE in Ciudad Juárez said that while they disliked the several-months-long waits for CBP One appointments, the app offered a process for entering the United States and turning themselves in to U.S. authorities that is “more orderly” and “a little safer.”

• “Frontera Mexico-Eu Esta Mas Ordenada por Medidas Cbp: Migrantes” (EFE, Milenio (Mexico), September 16, 2024).

11,023 Nicaraguans requested refuge in Costa Rica during the first 7 months of 2024, Nicaragua Investiga reported. While that is 9,280 fewer than the same period last year, it is not far behind the 17,868 Nicaraguan citizens whom U.S. authorities encountered at the U.S.-Mexico border during those 7 months.

• “Los Nicas Siguen Huyendo de Dictadura: Mas de 11,000 Llegaron a Costa Rica en Lo Que Va de 2024” (Nicaragua Investiga, September 17, 2024).

Texas Gov. Greg Abbott (R) designated Venezuela’s Tren de Aragua, an organized crime group, a “terrorist organization,” calling them “an extreme version of the heinous MS-13 gang.” Border Patrol union representative Chris Cabrera, present at the announcement, said, “As a federal agent, we have no way of vetting these people other than the honor system. If they tell us their name, we can’t check against Venezuela’s database.”

• “Governor Abbott Designates Tren de Aragua as Terrorist Organization” (Texas Governor’s Office, September 16, 2024).

Analyses and Feature Stories

The debunked, racist tropes that the Trump-Vance campaign issued in recent days are nothing new for Haitian migrants, wrote Nadra Nittle at the 19th: “Due to the unique ways race, religion and resistance have intersected in Haiti’s history, immigrants from the Caribbean nation have experienced a specific brand of xenophobia in the United States.”

• Nadra Nittle, “Trump’s Claims About Haitians Draw From a Centuries-Long Narrative. These Women Explain Why.” (The 19th, September 16, 2024).

“From what I’ve read and seen from Vice President Harris, I think she tries to take a balanced approach,” Adriel Orozco of the American Immigration Council told Mother Jones. “She tries to take a humanistic lens to migration, considering her background as a child of migrants, but she’s also a prosecutor.”

• Melvis Acosta, “What Immigration Experts Want From a Harris Administration” (Mother Jones, September 16, 2024).

Australian journalist Prue LeWarne reported about encounters with migrants—and migration agents—after journeying on Mexico’s “La Bestia” cargo train.

• Charlie Bell, Prue Lewarne, “I Travelled on Mexico’s Deadliest Train With Hundreds of Migrants Trying to Reach the Us” (SBS (Australia), September 16, 2024).

On the Right

• Jason Hopkins, “Biden Admin Touts Reduction in Border Crossings While Flying in Hundreds of Thousands of Migrants” (Daily Caller, September 17, 2024).

Get daily links in your email

Developments

Republican Vice Presidential candidate stood by his repeatedly debunked, racist claims that Haitian migrants in the city of Springfield, Ohio are consuming people’s pets. “If I have to create stories so that the American media actually pays attention to the suffering of the American people, then that’s what I’m going to do,” he told CNN.

• Maggie Astor, “Vance Sticks By Pet-Eating Claims and Says He’s Willing to ‘Create Stories’” (The New York Times, September 15, 2024).

Presidential candidate Donald Trump repeated the false claims about Haitians. In a post to his “Truth Social” network, Trump promised to terminate use of the CBP One app for port-of-entry appointments, suspend the refugee resettlement program, and return migrants—apparently including people currently documented with humanitarian parole, temporary protected status, pending asylum claims, and other statuses—“to their home countries.”

• Andy Sullivan, Gabriella Borter, Ted Hesson, “Haitian Americans Fear for Their Safety After Trump Repeats False Claims About Immigrants and Pets” (Reuters, Reuters, September 13, 2024).
• “Karoline Leavitt on Twitter” (Twitter, September 14, 2024).

The Washington Post covered “the merry-go-round”: Mexico’s ongoing effort, launched at the beginning of the year, to reduce migration to the U.S. border by massively busing about 10,000 non-Mexican migrants per month to the country’s south. “It’s unclear whether the results are sustainable. The number of migrants camped out in Mexican cities is rising.” In Villahermosa, Tabasco, where many southbound buses’ routes end, the city’s only migrant shelter is at double last year’s capacity.

• Mary Beth Sheridan, “How Mexico Is Helping Biden and Harris at the U.S. Border” (The Washington Post, September 14, 2024).

In Mexico’s northern-border city of Ciudad Juárez, from where many migrants are bused back south, the municipal government has closed one large migrant shelter and is converting a few community centers into new migrant shelters.

• Francisco Lujan, “Alcaldia Convirtio Espacios para Jovenes en Albergues para Migrantes” (Norte (Ciudad Juarez Mexico), September 14, 2024).

The independent Venezuelan daily Tal Cual found that a “wave” of people leaving Venezuela has yet to materialize following stolen July 28 elections. Still, “it is clear that there is an increase in migratory movements compared to previous months.” Venezuela’s El Pitazo reported that about 1,500 people per week are crossing from the Venezuelan border state of Zulia into Colombia’s department of La Guajira, a portion of whom intend to migrate overland to the United States.

• Daeni Pacheco, Luna Perdomo, “Aun No Hay Nueva Ola Migratoria de Venezolanos, Pero Miles Salen a Diario Desesperanzados” (Tal Cual (Venezuela), September 16, 2024).

Analyses and Feature Stories

A report from the Arizona-based Florence Immigrant and Refugee Rights Project, which plays a role in overseeing treatment of children in CBP custody, found that of children surveyed in 2023 and 2024, nearly 4 in 10 reported verbal abuse from Border Patrol agents, including racist and derogatory language. One in ten reported physical abuse like being pushed, kicked, or handcuffed. Children frequently reported being denied medical care.

• “Handcuffed, Pushed, and Afraid: Immigrant Children Share Terrifying Experiences While in Border Patrol Custody” (Florence Immigrant and Refugee Rights Project, September 13, 2024).

An Arizona Republic investigation found that nearly a quarter of human smuggling suspects arrested at Arizona’s border don’t get prosecuted “because Border Patrol agents failed to convey adequate probable cause before making a traffic stop or because migrants are unable to serve as material witnesses in a case.” It added, “countless others” have avoided prosecution due to COVID-19, lack of criminal history, or prosecutors’ “Tucson Sector guidelines” for prioritizing cases.

• Jason Wolf, “‘They Have Priorities’: 48 Hours in Tucson Sector at Arizona-Mexico Border” (The Arizona Republic, September 16, 2024).

“I have worked in the humanitarian field for almost 20 years and I have never seen what I saw regarding women crossing the Darién Gap,” the director of Human Rights Watch, Tirana Hassan, told Spain’s El País while on a visit to towns in northwestern Colombia from which migrants embark on the dangerous journey into Panama. “Sexual violence is so prevalent that they carry the morning-after pill when they begin the journey.” HRW published the third of three reports on the Darién Gap last week.

• Santiago Torrado, “Tirana Hassan: “la Violencia Sexual Es Tan Frecuente en el Darien Que las Mujeres Que Cruzan Llevan la Pildora del Dia Despues”” (El Pais (Spain), September 14, 2024).
• ““Muchos Venezolanos Volvieron a su Pais para Votar, Vieron Sus Esperanzas Destrozadas y Ahora Van a Arriesgar su Vida en el Darien”: Subdirector para las Americas de Hrw” (NTN24, September 13, 2024).

Get daily links in your email

Developments

Customs and Border Protection’s (CBP) Office of Professional Responsibility shared a report on Border Patrol agents’ participation in the delayed response to the 2022 school shooting in Uvalde, Texas, not far from the Del Rio-Eagle Pass border. As the New York Times described the report’s findings, “border agents had been just as confused and delayed as dozens of other state and local law enforcement agents inside the school by the chaotic and mostly leaderless response.”

• “U.S. Customs and Border Protection Releases Findings of Its Investigation of the Response to the Mass Shooting at Robb Elementary School in Uvalde, Texas” (U.S. Customs and Border Protection, September 12, 2024).
• Edgar Sandoval, J. David Goodman, “Border Agents Made Decision to Confront Gunman in Uvalde, Report Finds” (The New York Times, September 12, 2024).

The Haitian Times and Reuters reported about fear and threats spreading through Haitian immigrant communities around the United States after presidential candidate Donald Trump amplified false claims that migrants from Haiti were consuming people’s pets in an Ohio city. USA Today recalled that “pet-eating” is an old racist trope; the Intercept found a pattern of especially virulent discrimination against Haitian migrants in the United States.

• Macollvie J. Neel, “Haitian families in Ohio under attack as racist claims spread” (The Haitian Times, September 11, 2024).
• Andy Sullivan, Gabriella Borter, Ted Hesson, “Haitian Americans Fear for Their Safety After Trump Repeats False Claims About Immigrants and Pets” (Reuters, Reuters, September 13, 2024).
• Deborah Barfield Berry, Karen Weintraub, Lauren Villagran, “Immigrants-Eat-Pets Trope Is a Century-Old Stereotype and ‘Very Old Racism’” (USA Today, September 12, 2024).
• Jonah Valdez, “America’s Racist, Xenophobic, and Highly Specific Fear of Haiti” (The Intercept, September 12, 2024).

U.S. law enforcement officials interviewed by Border Report confirmed a Mexican police claim that traffickers have been using drones to move drugs from the border state of Chihuahua, including between more densely populated areas along the border between Ciudad Juárez and El Paso.

• Julian Resendiz, “Juarez Traffickers Using Drones to Drop Drugs in el Paso” (Border Report, September 12, 2024).

The House Homeland Security Committee’s Republican majority has scheduled a hearing for September 18 entitled, “A Country Without Borders: How Biden-Harris’ Open-Borders Policies Have Undermined Our Safety and Security.”

• “Media Advisory: Chairman Green Announces Hearing on the Biden-Harris Administration’s Catastrophic Border Record, Impacts on the Safety of Americans” (Committee on Homeland Security, U.S. House of Representatives, September 12, 2024).
• Anna Giaritelli, “House Republicans to Hold Biden-Harris Feet to Fire in Latest Border Crisis Hearing” (The Washington Examiner, September 12, 2024).

Analyses and Feature Stories

A new WOLA commentary amplified calls for a federal inquiry into Texas’s frequent use of soldiers (National Guard personnel) to confront unarmed asylum seekers, often violently. Because it involves military personnel on U.S. soil, appears to violate use-of-force standards and best practices for controlling disturbances, and is physically pushing protection-seeking migrants into Mexico, WOLA found this to be one of the most troubling aspects of Texas’s state “Operation Lone Star” border security crackdown.

• Adam Isacson, Ana Lucia Verduzco, “Soldiers Confronting Migrants: Texas’s Dangerous Precedent” (Washington Office on Latin America, September 12, 2024).

Newsweek looked at the numbers and spoke to experts who questioned Texas Gov. Greg Abbott’s (R) claim that Operation Lone Star has driven down the number of undocumented migrants there. The decline is border-wide.

• James Bickerton, “Greg Abbott Says Texas Border Is Solved—Is He Right?” (Newsweek, September 13, 2024).

In an interview with New York Times podcast host Ezra Klein, Department of Homeland Security (DHS) Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas defended the Biden administration’s border security and migration record, including its recent moves to restrict access to asylum at the border.

• Ezra Klein, “The Real ‘Border Czar’ Defends the Biden-Harris Record” (The New York Times, September 13, 2024).

On the Right

• Sarah Arnold, “First Biden-Harris Cbp One Bus Carrying Illegal Aliens Arrives at Border” (TownHall, September 12, 2024).
• James Bickerton, “Greg Abbott Says Texas ‘Won’t Back Down’ After Migrant Buoy Barrier Win” (Newsweek, September 12, 2024).

Get daily links in your email

Developments

Mexico’s migration agency posted video of the first bus transporting migrants across the country to their CBP One appointments at U.S. ports of entry. It departed Mexico’s southern border-zone city of Tapachula, destined for the U.S. border-zone city of Reynosa. Security-force personnel are to accompany the buses, which pass through areas dominated by organized crime.

• “Inm @inami_mx on Twitter” (Twitter, September 11, 2024).

In Ciudad Juárez, the municipal government’s “Kiki Romero” migrant shelter is closing. The border city’s population of migrants needing shelter has shrunk due to a Mexican government crackdown making transit of the country more difficult; a June Biden administration rule placing asylum out of reach for people who cross the border without a CBP One appointment; and the possibility of awaiting appointments using the backlogged app in other, usually safer, parts of Mexico.

• Julian Resendiz, “Juarez Shutting Down Shelter as Migrant Arrivals Plummet” (Border Report, September 11, 2024).

The U.S. State Department announced “visa restrictions on senior officials of a European charter flight company for facilitating irregular migration to the United States through Nicaragua.” Nicaragua’s dictatorship does not require many countries’ visitors to obtain visas before arrival, and many have used this aerial route to the Central American mainland as a way to request asylum at the U.S. border without having to pass through the Darién Gap.

• Matthew Miller, “Visa Restrictions on Senior Officials of a Charter Flight Company Facilitating Irregular Migration to the United States” (U.S. Department of State, September 11, 2024).

Mexican soldiers and national guardsmen raided a stash house near the Suchiate River, along Mexico’s border with Guatemala, freeing 52 men, 58 women and 28 minors, mainly from Honduras, Ecuador and Venezuela. No captors were arrested.

• Julio Navarro Cardenas, “Ejercito y Guardia Nacional Liberan a Migrantes Retenidos en Chiapas” (Milenio (Mexico), September 12, 2024).

Between October 2019 and July 2024, 9,885 Brazilian citizens—many of them encountered at the U.S.-Mexico border—were deported aboard more than 100 chartered flights to an airport in the state of Minas Gerais, sociologist Gustavo Dias wrote at Venezuela’s Tal Cual.

• Gustavo Dias, “Deportacion de Brasilenos: Una Tragedia Silenciosa” (Universidade Estadual de Montes Claros, Tal Cual (Venezuela), September 11, 2024).

Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva promised that his government would “help take care of the situation of” Venezuelan migrants entering Brazil following the Caracas government’s false claim to have won July 28 presidential elections, EFE reported.

• “Lula Gestionara Con «Responsabilidad» y «Respeto» el Aumento de Migrantes Venezolanos” (EFE, Efecto Cocuyo (Venezuela), September 11, 2024).

Analyses and Feature Stories

The Wall Street Journal reported on the U.S. presence of the Tren de Aragua, a Venezuelan organized-crime group that has begun to receive the level of attention that El Salvador’s MS-13 gang did during the Trump administration. Some of the group’s members appear to be sprinkled in among the approximately 700,000 Venezuelan citizens encountered at the U.S.-Mexico border since fiscal 2021. A “high-ranking Immigration and Customs Enforcement [ICE] official” told the Journal that “there are now more than 100 investigations in the U.S. involving suspected members of Tren de Aragua.”

In April, Insight Crime’s Venezuela Investigative Unit had reported: “the few crimes attributed to alleged Tren de Aragua members in the United States appear to have no connection with the larger group or its leadership in Venezuela. And none of more than a dozen national, state, and local law enforcement agencies contacted by InSight Crime has reported any significant presence of Tren de Aragua.”

• Juan Forero, “A Venezuelan Gang Is Expanding Its Deadly Reach to the U.S.” (The Wall Street Journal, September 12, 2024).

In the Denver suburb of Aurora, Colorado, the Republican mayor and a Republican city council member put out a statement downplaying claims, amplified by Trump and other national Republican political leaders, that the city is suffering a wave of Tren de Aragua-related crime.

• Alayna Alvarez, “Aurora Leaders Backtrack On “Overstated” Claims of Venezuelan Gang Activity” (Axios, September 11, 2024).

Several border and migration-related analyses followed the September 10 presidential candidates’ debate between Trump and Vice President Kamala Harris.

The New York Times reported that Republican candidate Donald Trump’s recurrence to anti-migrant “vitriol” has become even more frequent than it was in earlier campaigns. Reporters Hamed Aleaziz, Jazmine Ulloa, Michael D. Shear assert that Trump’s move into more extreme territory is, at least in part, a reaction to the Democratic Party’s own rightward shift on the immigration issue since 2021.

• Hamed Aleaziz, Jazmine Ulloa, Michael D. Shear, “How Trump Uses Vitriol for Migrants to Sideline Other Issues” (The New York Times, September 11, 2024).

Ian Millhiser published an explainer at Vox about the “racist, cat-eating conspiracy theory” that Trump amplified.

• Ian Millhiser, “Republicans’ Racist, Cat-Eating Conspiracy Theory, Briefly Explained” (Vox, September 11, 2024).

Newsweek reviewed Trump’s false or misleading claims about pet-eating, crime committed by migrants, migrants taking jobs from U.S. citizens, Harris’s border-policy responsibilities within the Biden administration, and Harris’s alleged support for gender transition surgeries in migrant detention centers.

• Billal Rahman, Dan Gooding, “‘Venezuela on Steroids’ and Other Immigration Claims in Harris v Trump” (Newsweek, September 11, 2024).

At Mother Jones, Isabela Dias lamented that Trump’s positions framed the debate’s vision of immigration: “The only political points made on immigration on stage were about enforcement.”

• Isabela Dias, “The Debate Exposed How Comfortable America Is With Hating Immigrants” (Mother Jones, September 11, 2024).

Get daily links in your email

Developments

Migration was a principal topic at the September 10 presidential campaign debate between Vice President Kamala Harris and former president Donald Trump.

Without offering much specifics, Harris portrayed herself as a former border-state prosecutor whose “tough on border security” credentials included past efforts against cross-border organized crime.

Harris reiterated support for a bill, which failed in the U.S. Senate in February even though Democratic and Republican senators had negotiated a compromise, that “would have put 1,500 more border agents on the border” and “would have allowed us to stem the flow of fentanyl.” That bill also included restrictions on access to asylum similar to those that the Biden administration imposed in June; Harris did not mention asylum though it was part of the debate moderator’s question.

Donald Trump’s frequent, vitriolic, and often false comments about the border and migrants (whom he said “have destroyed the fabric of our country”) provided the debate with some of its most colorful and remarked-upon moments. The Los Angeles Times’ Andrea Castillo cited several occasions when the former president steered his remarks back to his antipathy toward migration, even when another topic was at hand. (Harris derailed Trump, though, during the migration discussion, leading him to use up much allotted response time responding to a comment about his public rallies.)

Trump leaned all the way into false claims, amplified earlier on right-wing social media, that Haitian migrants in Springfield, Ohio were “eating the dogs…eating the cats” of the town’s residents. Trump also raised allegations that migrants are contributing to rising violent crime in the United States. Debate moderators fact-checked both claims: nobody is eating pets in Springfield, and U.S. crime rates are actually falling.

• Riley Hoffman, “Read: Harris-Trump presidential debate transcript” (ABC News, September 10, 2024).
• Andrea Castillo, “Why Trump Kept Going Back to Immigration Again and Again” (The Los Angeles Times, September 11, 2024).
• Avery Lotz, “Biden Admin Condemns “Dangerous” Conspiracy About Haitian Immigrants” (Axios, September 10, 2024).
• Kevin Rector, “Trump Says Crime Is Soaring, and Immigrants Are to Blame. The Data Tell Another Story” (The Los Angeles Times, September 10, 2024).
• Salome Ramirez Vargas, “Harris y Trump se Embisten en Primer Debate, Con Inmigracion Como Protagonista” (VOA, Tal Cual (Venezuela), September 11, 2024).

NPR’s Jasmine Garsd found that racist anti-immigrant movements have a long history of accusing migrants of consuming house pets.

• Jasmine Garsd, “The Stereotype of Immigrants Eating Dogs and Cats Is Storied — and Vitriolic as Ever” (National Public Radio, September 11, 2024).

At the Intercept, Natasha Lennard lamented that Harris’s remarks didn’t include even standard liberal rhetoric about immigrants’ many positive contributions to the United States.

• Natasha Lennard, “Kamala Harris Accepted Trump’s Racist Lie That Immigration Is Bad” (The Intercept, September 11, 2024).

The Washington Post published an overview of what Kamala Harris and Donald Trump have said on the record about deporting undocumented people, pathways to U.S. citizenship, separating migrant families, and policy toward refugees and asylum seekers.

• Abbie Cheeseman, Anthony J. Rivera, Justine Mcdaniel, Maria Sacchetti, “Harris vs. Trump on Immigration: Where They Stand on the Issue” (The Washington Post, September 10, 2024).

Texas state Attorney-General Ken Paxton (R), who has been on a legal offensive against charities that assist migrants released from CBP custody along the border, filed a new petition seeking to overrule an earlier judge’s refusal to order a sworn deposition of Sister Norma Pimentel, the director of Catholic Charities of the Rio Grande Valley.

• Dina Arevalo, “Texas Ag Continues Effort to Depose, Shut Down Catholic Charities” (The Brownsville Herald, September 10, 2024).

At the Border Chronicle, Melissa del Bosque compared Attorney-General Paxton’s harassment of NGOs to those of authoritarian leaders elsewhere in the world who have sought to close down independent organizations, like Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán or Guatemalan prosecutor Rafael Curruchiche.

• Melissa del Bosque, “The Authoritarian Playbook” (The Border Chronicle, September 10, 2024).

Analyses and Feature Stories

Human Rights Watch published a third report since November on the Darién Gap, this one focused on how migration policies in Brazil, Chile, Colombia, Ecuador, Panama, and Peru have complicated regularization and integration of Haitian and Venezuelan migrants, driving many to depart for the United States via the treacherous jungle route.

• “Americas: Limited Protection for People Fleeing Venezuela, Haiti” (Human Rights Watch, September 11, 2024).

A study published in the journal Injury Epidemiology found that adults migrating toward the United States “are extorted on average $804 per research participant throughout the journey.” The most common extortion perpetrators that 85 respondents cited were police officers (80.6%), immigration officials (37.3%), organized crime (25.4%), and military personnel (20.9%). Extortion happened most often in Mexico (77.6%) and Guatemala (67.2%), two countries that seek to block, detain, and deport migrants as a matter of policy.

• Kelsea Pieters, “Researchers Identify Another Common and Harmful Experience Among Latinx Immigrants Traveling to the Us: Extortion” (University of Colorado Anschutz Medical Campus, September 10, 2024).

The Mexican government’s implementation of measures to facilitate migrants’ journey to the U.S. border for CBP One appointments “has been slow and chaotic,” reported the independent Cuban news outlet El Toque. “many migrants remain stranded in [Mexico’s southern border-zone city of] Tapachula without access to transportation or the necessary permits.”

• Yenys Laura Prieto, “Cbp One y Movilidad Segura en Mexico: Lo Que Nadie Te Ha Contado” (El Toque (Cuba), September 10, 2024).

On the Right

• Anna Giaritelli, “Harris Backed Slashing Ice and Funding Gender-Transition Surgeries for Illegal Immigrants” (The Washington Examiner, September 10, 2024).

Get daily links in your email

Developments

Panama’s National Migration Service posted on the morning of September 9 that 244,243 people had migrated through the Darién Gap. That means 6,058 people passed through the treacherous region during the first 8 days of September: 757 per day, which is 41 percent more than August’s average of 536 per day.

• “Migración Panamá @migracionpanama on Twitter“ (Twitter, September 9, 2024).

The Harris-Walz campaign published a document outlining Democratic candidate Kamala Harris’s policy positions. On the border and migration, the document backs the “Border Act,” the product of a compromise with Republicans that failed in the Senate in February, calling it “the strongest reform in decades.” It adds that this bill “would have deployed more detection technology to intercept fentanyl and other drugs and added 1,500 border security agents to protect our border.”

The document does not mention the Border Act’s intent to change U.S. law to place asylum out of reach between ports of entry at moments when migrant apprehensions are high. A June White House rule implemented a similar asylum restriction; the campaign document does not specifically mention that, but notes that Vice President Harris “and President Biden took action on their own—and now border crossings are at the lowest level in 4 years.”

• “A New Way Forward” (Harris-Walz Campaign, September 9, 2024).

In tonight’s presidential campaign debate, Donald Trump “is almost certain to lob many of his criticisms of Harris on the issue of border security,” observed a USA Today analysis.

• Kathryn Palmer, “Republicans Attack Harris on Border Ahead of Presidential Debate” (USA Today, The Desert Sun, September 9, 2024).

On the Trump campaign’s side of things, the former president’s migration advisor, Stephen Miller, promised a “100% perfect deportation rate at the border,” using “Title 42/Safe 3rds/Remain in Mexico/Asylum Bars” if Trump is elected, in a Twitter exchange with billionaire Mark Cuban. The campaign and other Republican surrogates amplified false and racist rumors that Haitian migrants were consuming people’s pets in the town of Springfield, Ohio.

• Billal Rahman, “Trump Immigration Policy: Adviser Promises “100% Deportation Rate”” (Newsweek, September 10, 2024).
• Chris Cameron, “Trump Campaign Amplifies False Claim About Haitian Migrants in Ohio” (The New York Times, September 9, 2024).
• Rafael Bernal, “Vance Pushes False Accusations of Haitians Eating Pets” (The Hill, September 9, 2024).

The House Judiciary Committee’s Republican majority is holding two “Biden-Harris border crisis” hearings today: one on “victim perspectives” and one on “noncitizen voting.”

• Anna Giaritelli, “Mother of Daughter Killed by Ms-13 Illegal Immigrant Brings Fight to Washington” (The Washington Examiner, September 9, 2024).

The Embassy of India in Mexico issued an advisory warning Indian citizens against travel in Mexico, citing the likelihood of prolonged detentions and deportations by Mexican forces, after three years of increasing numbers of Indian citizens passing through the country as they seek to migrate to the United States.

• Huma Siddiqui, “India Issues Strong Advisory Amid Increasing Immigration Struggles at Mexico’s Border” (Financial Express (India), September 10, 2024).

Texas Gov. Greg Abbott (R) said that he would defy an International Boundary and Water Commission order to dismantle “sediment bridges” and concertina wire that the state’s security forces built on Fronton Island, which lies in the Rio Grande in Starr County, south Texas.

• James Bickerton, “Greg Abbott Defies Joe Biden Order in Texas Border Battle” (Newsweek, September 10, 2024).

Analyses and Feature Stories

The dangerous, organized crime-dominated passage across Mexico leaves migrants with post-traumatic stress. Kidnappings are the biggest trigger, a Ciudad Juárez-based lawyer with Jesuit Refugee Service told EFE. An anti-kidnapping organization reported two mass kidnappings of a total of 36 migrants, and 196 migrant kidnappings overall, just in July in Chihuahua, the state that includes Ciudad Juárez.

• “Migrantes Padecen Estres Postraumatico Tras la Violencia en Mexico” (EFE, Milenio (Mexico), September 9, 2024).

“The preservation of borders in the face of climate catastrophe, global conflict, and regular economic crises will require ever greater internal and external violence,” warns Jake Romm in a Nation review of John Washington’s 2024 book The Case for Open Borders.

• Jake Romm, “Imagining a World of Open Borders” (The Nation, September 10, 2024).

On the Right

• Bethany Blankley, “Harris Says She Will Build a Border Wall, Majority Polled Don’t Believe Her” (The Center Square, September 9, 2024).
• Diana Glebova, “Kamala Harris Vows to Grant Amnesty to Migrants Who Illegally Cross Border: ‘Earned Pathway to Citizenship’” (The New York Post, September 9, 2024).

Get daily links in your email

Developments

For the first time in three months, Panama has updated official statistics about migration through the treacherous Darién Gap jungle region.

• 238,185 people migrated through the Darién Gap during the first 8 months of 2024. That is 29 percent fewer than during the first 8 months of 2023 (333,704).
• The number of migrants transiting the Darién fell from 31,049 in June 2024, to 20,526 in July, to 16,596 in August. The August total was the fewest since June 2022.
• 71 percent of migrants in August were citizens of Venezuela. During the first 8 months of 2024, 67 percent of migrants were from Venezuela.
• In June, Ecuador suspended visas for arriving citizens of China. For now at least, the number of Chinese migrants passing through the Darién Gap has plummeted: from 1,074 in June, to 772 in July, to 53 in August.

The drop in Darién Gap migration is probably a short-term “wait and see” effect, as migrants and smugglers pause to evaluate the changes being implemented by Panamanian President José Raúl Mulino, who was inaugurated on July 1. Mulino has ordered barbed wire laid across some jungle routes, and has launched, with U.S. support, a deportation program that is sending a few planeloads of migrants back to their countries of origin every week.

• “Tránsito Irregular por Darién” (Migración Panama, updated September 6, 2024).
• Todd Bensman, “Progress Report: Has Panama Closed the Notorious ‘Darien Gap’ Mass Migration Route to the U.S. Border as Promised?” (Center for Immigration Studies, September 9, 2024).

Panama sent a U.S.-funded deportation flight to India, with 130 people aboard, on September 6. Thomas Cartwright of Witness at the Border cited a “believable” report that the flight cost $700,000 or “$5,400 per person.” On September 7, a smaller plane carried 29 people from Panama to Colombia, the fifth flight to Colombia since August 9.

• “Thcartwright @Thcartwright on Twitter” (Twitter, September 6, 2024).
• “U.S. Embassy Panama @Usembpan on Twitter” (Twitter, September 6, 2024).
• “Thcartwright @thcartwright on Twitter” (Twitter, September 7, 2024).
• “Migración Panamá @migracionpanama on Twitter” (Twitter, September 8, 2024).

Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) sent a deportation flight to Cap-Haïtien, Haiti on September 6. It was the first such flight since July, and came the day after Secretary of State Anthsony Blinken visited the violence-plagued nation.

• “Thcartwright @Thcartwright on Twitter” (Twitter, September 6, 2024).

Border Patrol’s San Diego Sector reported 3,557 migrant apprehensions during the most recent week, right in the middle of the range reported since late June (3,063 to 3,958). Border Patrol’s Tucson Sector reported 2,700 migrant apprehensions last week, right in the middle of the range reported since late June (2,400 to 2,900).

• Chief Patrol Agent Patricia D. Mcgurk-Daniel @Usbpchiefsdc on Twitter (Twitter, September 4, 2024).
• “John R. Modlin @Usbpchieftca on Twitter” (Twitter, September 6, 2024).

Reporting from the border city of Cúcuta, Colombia, Santiago Torrado of Spain’s El País found no increase in migration from Venezuela following the Nicolás Maduro regime’s false claims to have won July 28 elections. Local authorities, however, are anxiously expecting “a new migratory wave.”

• Santiago Torrado, “La Frontera Colombiana Aguarda Con Nerviosismo el Desenlace de la Crisis Poselectoral de Venezuela” (El Pais (Spain), September 8, 2024).

The late August expansion of the CBP One smartphone app’s geographic coverage to Mexico’s two southernmost states has saturated migrant shelters in Chiapas and Tabasco, La Jornada reported. The director of Tapachula’s El Buen Pastor shelter said that she is now serving 2,000 migrants per day, up from 600 to 700 before August 23, when people could begin using CBP One from Chiapas.

• Jared Laureles, Jessica Xantomila, “Pedido de Asilo a Eu via Cbp One Satura Refugios en Frontera de Chiapas” (La Jornada (Mexico), September 8, 2024).

“This is the first time in my 20 to 22 years of government service that I see a state act in direct contravention of national interests,” Department of Homeland Security (DHS) Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas said of Texas Gov. Greg Abbott’s (R) hardline border and migration policies in an appearance at the annual Texas Tribune Festival.

• Uriel J. Garcia, “Mayorkas: Texas’ Immigration Policies Have Wreaked Havoc and Disorder” (The Texas Tribune, September 6, 2024).

“In Colorado, they’re so brazen, they’re taking over sections of the state,” Donald Trump said at a Wisconsin campaign rally, apparently referring to since–debunked claims that members Venezuela’s Tren de Aragua organized-crime group who arrived over the southern border had taken over apartment buildings in the Denver suburb of Aurora. “And you know, getting them out will be a bloody story. They should never have been allowed to come into our country. Nobody checked them.” Some analysts noted with alarm that the candidate promising “mass deportations” predicted that they would be “bloody.”

• David Frum, “Trump Promises a ‘Bloody Story’” (The Atlantic, September 8, 2024).
• Ben Makuch, “Neo-Nazi and Far Right Groups Seize on Trump’s Anti-Immigration Rhetoric” (The Guardian (Uk), September 8, 2024).

In California last Friday, Republican vice presidential candidate JD Vance visited the borderline with local Republican politicians and Border Patrol agents. At “Whiskey 8,” the site along the border wall near San Diego where until recently many asylum seekers had been turning themselves in to U.S. authorities, the Ohio senator refused to disavow future migrant family separations under a second Trump administration.

Meanwhile in Santee, in San Diego county, House Judiciary Committee Republicans held a field hearing entitled “The Biden-Harris Border Crisis: California Perspectives.”

• Alexandra Mendoza, “Republicans Focus on U.S.-Mexico Border During Congressional Hearing and Vance San Diego Visit” (The San Diego Union-Tribune, September 6, 2024).
• Andrea Castillo, “In California Hearing About the Border, House Gop Seeks to Attack Harris in Her Home State” (The Los Angeles Times, September 6, 2024).
• Alec Hernández and Jacob Soboroff, “Vance declines to rule out the use of family separations if Trump is re-elected” (NBC News, September 6, 2024).
• Salvador Rivera, “Jd Vance Guarded by Snipers During Border Visit to San Diego-Tijuana Area” (Border Report, September 6, 2024).
• Anna Giaritelli, “Californians in Fourth Year of Border Crisis Blame Biden-Harris” (The Washington Examiner, September 6, 2024).
• Josh Marcus, “Vance Insists John Mccain Wouldn’t Have Supported Harris if He Saw the Border” (The Independent (UK), September 7, 2024).

Mexican “children as young as nine, 11, and 16 were involved in separate drug seizures this week” at the San Luis port of entry near Yuma, Arizona, Border Report reported.

• Julian Resendiz, “Cbp: Cartel Using Kids to Smuggle Fentanyl” (Border Report, September 6, 2024).

Analyses and Feature Stories

At the Christian Science Monitor, Jody García explored whether the U.S. government’s new tactic of issuing indictments and extradition requests for migrant smugglers in Guatemala might affect smuggling organizations’ “business model.” A top official in Guatemala’s migration agency pointed out that “without international cooperation, arrests like these may not result in much, especially in a country where collaborations between criminal groups and local police are commonplace.”

• Jody Garcia, “Human Smuggling Is on the Rise. International Collaboration Is Key to Halting It.” (The Christian Science Monitor, September 6, 2024).

CNN fact-checked Donald Trump’s claim that “more terrorists have come into the United States in the last three years. And I think probably 50 years.” Peter Bergen noted that many more people on the FBI’s terror watchlist have entered from Canada than from Mexico.

• Peter Bergen, “Trump’s Claim Terrorists Are Pouring Over Southern Border Does Not Stand Up to Scrutiny” (CNN, September 8, 2024).

At USA Today, Lauren Villagrán profiled Michael DeBruhl, a former Border Patrol agent who runs El Paso’s Sacred Heart Church migrant shelter. “As you rise in the organization [Border Patrol], the higher you go, the better the picture is on the larger issues,” he observed.

• Lauren Villagran, “After 26 Years, a Border Patrol Agent Has a New Role: Helping Migrants” (USA Today, September 8, 2024).

On the Right

• Billal Rahman, “Ted Cruz Claims Mexico “Aiding” Cartels to Traffic Migrants” (Newsweek, September 9, 2024).
• Rachel Dobkin, “Fox News Host Questions Texas Republican on Opposition to Border Bill” (Newsweek, September 8, 2024).