Developments
Citing “preliminary figures,” Reuters reported that Border Patrol apprehended about 54,000 migrants at the U.S.-Mexico border in October. That is almost identical to September’s apprehension number (53,858) and very similar to July’s (56,400) and August’s (58,009).
Dual crackdowns—Mexico’s stepped-up blocking and southward busing of migrants, and the Biden administration’s June asylum restrictions—continue to keep apprehensions at their lowest level since September 2020. However, the number stopped declining months ago.
- Ted Hesson, “Us Border Arrests Remained Lower in October Amid Biden Asylum Restrictions, Source Says” (Reuters, msn.com, November 1, 2024).
On October 31, Panamanian President José Raúl Mulino said that the number of migrants transiting the treacherous Darién Gap would likely be “a little more than 21,542.” That would be a modest drop in Darién Gap migration from 25,111 in September. Citizens of Venezuela remain by far the number-one nationality.
Mulino said that, mainly with U.S. support, Panama has run 23 deportation flights since early August, sending about 800 people primarily to Colombia and Ecuador but some to China and India. The president, who took office in July, reiterated the terms of an October 25 decree instituting steep fines for people, like Darién border-crossers, who enter the country without authorization.
- “Panama: Mas de 196 Mil Migrantes Venezolanos Cruzaron el Darien en Lo Que Va de Ano” (Tal Cual (Venezuela), November 1, 2024).
- “Gobierno de Panama Sancionara Con Millonarias Multas a Migrantes Que Crucen el Darien Desde Colombia” (NTN24, October 31, 2024).
The U.S. government sent a deportation flight to Haiti on October 31 with 77 people aboard, even as a gang offensive is intensifying, the Miami Herald reported. On October 26, a gang coalition called Viv Ansanm looted and burned a Missionaries of Charity convent and hospital in Port-au-Prince, which Mother Teresa had inaugurated in 1979.
- Jacqueline Charles, Syra Ortiz Blanes, “U.S. Deportation Flight Lands in Haiti Amid Spreading Violence, Attack on Catholic Nuns” (The Miami Herald, October 31, 2024).
In Mexico’s southern border-zone city of Tapachula, Chiapas, hundreds of people with confirmed appointments at U.S. border ports of entry, made using the CBP One app, are “saturating” the local offices of Mexico’s migration agency (National Migration Institute, INM), La Jornada reported. They are demanding that the agency issue permits allowing them to transit Mexican territory to attend their appointments. It is unclear whether the backlog owes to any changes at INM, which has offered to coordinate protected travel from Chiapas for at least some of those with appointments.
- Edgar H. Clemente, “Saturan Migrantes Oficina del Inm en Chiapas” (La Jornada (Mexico), October 31, 2024).
Analyses and Feature Stories
As migrant smuggling organizations have become wealthier and more sophisticated, U.S. law enforcement agencies are struggling to catch up, facing resource, judicial, and intelligence gaps, concluded a Washington Post investigation, focusing on a case in Guatemala, by Mexico-Central America correspondent Mary Beth Sheridan. U.S. agencies are also hampered by decades of focus specifically on drug trafficking instead of human smuggling, and by partner nations’ official corruption.
- Mary Beth Sheridan, “As Smuggling Rings Made Billions From Migrants, the U.S. Was Sidelined” (The Washington Post, November 1, 2024).
Five organizations, including border-area service providers, released a report about climate-related migration, finding that the expected increase in people fleeing climate change is now happening. The report provides data on responses from over 3,600 migrants whom Al Otro Lado, Haitian Bridge Alliance, International Refugee Assistance Project, and Las Americas Immigrant Advocacy Center have served, including over 3,000 from the Americas. Of those from the Americas, 43 percent “reported experiencing environmental disasters such as hurricanes, droughts, extreme heat, and floods in their home countries.” The report recommends expanding legal immigration pathways for climate refugees and victims.
- “Groundbreaking Data Report Documents the Impact of Climate Change Disasters on People Seeking Immigration Relief in the United States” (Al Otro Lado, Haitian Bridge Alliance, International Refugee Assistance Project, Las Americas Immigrant Advocacy Center, International Refugee Assistance Project, October 31, 2024).
The International Refugee Assistance Project issued a “practice advisory” clarifying that Cuban, Haitian, Nicaraguan, and Venezuelan recipients of two years’ humanitarian parole, under a Biden administration initiative that has helped reduce border apprehensions from those nationalities, still have the right to apply for a renewal of their parole status. Many descriptions of an early October Biden administration policy change have erroneously interpreted it as refusing parole renewals; the change, in fact, specifies that while there is no “re-parole process,” it remains true that “any individual parolee may apply to renew their parole.”
- “Practice Advisory: Chnv Parolees May Apply to Renew Parole Even Without a Parole Renewal Process” (International Refugee Assistance Project, October 31, 2024).
In a report from San Diego and Tijuana at KQED News, Tyche Hendricks explained the recent decline in the number of migrants arriving at the border, the crackdowns and legal pathways that enabled it, human rights concerns, and the likelihood that lower numbers might persist.
- Tyche Hendricks, “Despite Election Rhetoric, Illegal Border Crossings Sit at 4-Year Low” (KQED News, November 1, 2024).
The San Diego-based iNewSource reported from Tijuana where large numbers of migrants, including Mexican citizens fleeing violence in their own country, are enduring long waits for appointments at U.S. ports of entry using the CBP One app. While they wait, migrant children are showing signs of regression and trauma, while parents struggle with emotional distress. One family interviewed by reporter Sofía Mejías-Pascoe has waited over a year for a CBP One appointment. “Asylum isn’t something you can schedule,” said Christina Asencio of Human Rights First.
- Sofia Mejias-Pascoe, “Asylum Seekers in Mexico Wait Months on End to Enter U.S.” (inewsource, November 1, 2024).
At the Border Chronicle, Todd Miller reflected on the prominent role that the border and its barrier continue to play in a third consecutive U.S. election campaign. “Contemplating Trump’s rhetoric decrying U.S. ‘open borders’ while in the shadow of the wall is absurd,” Miller concluded.
- Todd Miller, “The Election and the Future of the Wall” (The Border Chronicle, October 31, 2024).
At the Progressive, Jeff Abbott examined the harm that a “mass deportation” campaign, which U.S. presidential candidate Donald Trump is promising, would do to economic and political stability in Central America. Sending millions of Central American migrants back to impoverished countries, thus halting remittance flows, “would be the worst catastrophe that could possibly occur. It would be worse than a major earthquake,” said a former president of El Salvador’s central bank.
- Jeff Abbott, “What Trump’s Plan to Deport Millions of Immigrants Will Mean for Central America” (The Progressive, October 31, 2024).
At USA Today, Nick Penzenstadler and Lauren Villagrán examined how much the federal government might have to pay to carry out Trump’s plan, and how handsomely its private contractors would profit.
- Lauren Villagran, Nick Penzenstadler, “Trump’s Deportation Plan: A Cost to Taxpayers, Billions for Big Business” (USA Today, October 31, 2024).
The Associated Press profiled Sam Schultz, a 69-year-old volunteer who shuns politics and doggedly provides daily assistance to migrants waiting to be processed for asylum in the cold, rugged hills near the border around Jacumba Springs, California.
- Gregory Bull, “A Quaker Who Helps Migrants Says Us Presidential Election Will Make No Difference at the Border” (Associated Press, Associated Press, October 31, 2024).
On the Right
- Tara Mergener, “Biden’s Border Policies Under Fire as App Paroles 800,000 Migrants Into the Us” (CBN News, October 31, 2024).